JW411
I think that you are perhaps being a little aggressive here. At least Alex Whittingham is using his name on this forum. He is one of the most well known and highly respected trainers in JAR ATPL subjects in the UK.
His point is well put but perhaps you are undestandably sensitive and 'close' to the particular example discussed on this subject, hence the tension. Have a think about it and perhaps come back with your thoughts when things are a bit calmer.