PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - R/T question
Thread: R/T question
View Single Post
Old 18th November 2005 | 00:36
  #22 (permalink)  
spekesoftly
20 Anniversary
 
Joined: Aug 2001
Posts: 1,924
Likes: 7
From: UK
"Currently approaching Little Piddle-on-the-Gusset, G-CD"

Simple and unambiguous.
Sorry BEags, but I totally disagree, on several counts.

Firstly, what the fcuk does approaching mean? Three, Five, Ten, Fifteen, Twenty miles to run? And from which direction - N/W/S/E?

Now let's turn this around for a moment, with ATC giving Traffic Info, based on pilot reports, to other aircraft for example. Which would you, as a pilot, find more useful?:-

"G-CD, traffic is a PA28 currently approaching XXX ..........."

OR

"G-CD, traffic is a PA28 five (miles) south of XXX .......... "

Now I'm not too fussed about the five miles being hyper-accurate, but the 2nd example does give ATC, and other Airspace users, a far better picture.

Imagine a busy VFR sunny week-end. During the course of several hours, many dozens of light aircraft will make position reports. If they all include the totally meaningless "Currently Approaching", that can add up to a heck of a lot of wasted words.

Please guys, R/T time is a very precious commodity - Say Something Useful!
spekesoftly is offline