PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - 737-200 banked 87 deg?
View Single Post
Old 8th Nov 2005, 06:39
  #21 (permalink)  
chuks
 
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Germany
Age: 76
Posts: 1,561
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Here we go again with the old debate about 'hand-flying' skills vs. being able to speed-type commands into the FMS and never, ever needing to hand-fly since that must mean that someone made a boo-boo.

One that was a particular wake-up call was the so-called Roselawn accident in the States, when a load of ice accumulated while the aircraft was on autopilot in a holding pattern. When the autopilot released, having reached its force limit, 'twang!' went the ailerons and the airplane augered in. It turned out that the crew would have had to put in fairly massive amounts of roll force to get the wings level, when they assumed the ailerons were locked. It was after that one that recommendations about not using the autopilot in icing came out.

What I am getting at here is an obvious tendency to sit there and watch 'What's it doing now?' rather than jump in with a timely hand-flown intervention. There are arguments for and against this, of course, but the trend seems to be to sit and watch for perhaps too long. I have often had points deducted on simulator checks for perfectly correct control inputs simply because these were hand-flown.

I went on a European trip last weekend in a series of bizjets, with the last leg in a new Falcon 2000 EASI. It seemed that the (admittedly wonderful) cockpit technology took away a lot of attention from looking outside to see what was happening in the real world. Virtual reality ruled, there. Of course I am used to Africa, so that I am keeping an open mind about how it's done in Europe these days, when I have a lot to learn.
chuks is offline