Hey Smiley,
There are two basic methods of checklist usage - "do list" and "checklist." Either way is okay so long as the method is consistent throughout the fleet. If the training capt's have there own methods, it sounds like the standards department has some work to do.
NASA has done some great research on checklist format/design and usage. You might be able to google it. Otherwise try the US Gov't Printing Office website.
Best,
Jim