PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - What's the latest news of the V22 Osprey?
Old 1st Oct 2005, 05:08
  #82 (permalink)  
Dave_Jackson
 
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: Vancouver, BC, Canada
Posts: 1,635
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Mart,

"Tiltrotor will never be as efficient in hover, but counterrotor is unlikely to be as efficient in high speed flight."
They both have latterly located counter-rotating twin main rotors. The concern is; which configuration can significantly improve high-speed flight without jeopardizing hover (payload).

The primary differences between the tilt-rotor configuration and the ABC-rotor configuration are the means of propulsion and the means of lift.

Tilt-rotors ~
~ Hover ~ Uses the rotors.
~ Forward flight ~ Uses the rotors (props) for propulsors, and separate wings for lift.
~ The prop/rotors are not ideal as rotors nor are they ideal as propellers.

ABC-rotors ~
~ Hover ~ Uses the rotors.
~ Forward flight ~ Uses separate props for propulsors, and the rotors as wings.
~ The ABC-rotors are not ideal as rotors nor are they ideal as wings.

For reasonable fast forward flight, my money is on the ABC-rotors over the tilt-rotors.

For very fast forward flight, my money is on Reverse-velocity-rotors over the tilt-rotors. It will be a lot easier to produce a craft with reverse-velocity-rotors and fan-jets then trying to morph the tilting rotors into fan-jets during transition.

The next question then becomes Coaxial, Interleaving, Intermeshing or Side-by-side?
Dave_Jackson is offline