Really don't think we should waste too much time on the likes of 6foottanker, obviously not yet in a command position and still to be tried and tested, no previous experience of decision making and possibly already 'career orientated' away from such possibilities.
RHS VC10 year 2005 doesn't exactly leap out as the future leader, does it?
Crap Pilot, take all the sensible advice you can get, throw it into the balance and then toss a coin, if it comes down and fills you with dissapointment, ignore it and do the other thing, if it fills you with pleasure, follow it! You have but one life.