I know better than to contradict you. If I do, poor old bpilatus will be forced to start abusing me in fantasy-Greek again.
I love the idea that people will give me something for free when I go flying. The flipside is that such a scheme is open to deliberate abuse by some, and to inadvertant abuse by those who simply don't bother doing any pre-flight planning.
Nobody is arguing about the idea of an alternate. Why diverting to your planned alternate should be something that you need to be incentivised to do, is less clear. If your (one's) decision making is sufficiently bad that it
needs that prompt, perhaps flying is not for you?
2D