Wow. haven't visited this thread for a while.
I didn't realise that there were so many managers on here, a Pilots' forum. Or at least that's what it seems like.
Those professional pilots running down a person who has forged the way to improve T's & C's should be ashamed of themselves, or at least examine their motivation.
Having read the tribunal judgement it appears that they were not convinced by BA's arguments. The better case won on the day. It seems that some EMPLOYEES have difficulty dealing with that. Pity.