I am sorry to still see that some of the pilots on this forum continue to feel that debate about their decision making should only be among themselves and to exclude :
The designers of the aircraft and its engines
The regulators who crafted the rules and their basis
Accident investigators who have access to historical comparisons
Recognized and published aviation safety proffessionals.
So far the owner of this site has seen fit not to exclude this broader base of discussion.
The problem with limiting the discussion is that the outcome will continued to be second guessed by the public and there will be nobody to defend your decisions or the right to make them.