PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - Helicopter crash Scotland: Pilot prosecuted. VERDICT
Old 4th Feb 2005, 15:01
  #56 (permalink)  
Flying Lawyer
 
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: London
Posts: 2,916
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
STOP PRESS

Captain Iain Grindley was ACQUITTED of Reckless Endangering a few minutes ago.

Charge 1: Recklessly Endangering
(a) re flying low level over the North Sea: Not Guilty (Unanimous)
(b) re flying low level over the disused railway line: Not Guilty (Unanimous)
(c) re colliding with the wires: Not Proven (Unanimous)
(Charge 1 originally had 5 parts, but the Prosecutor withdrew 2 during the trial.)

Note: Not Proven is a verdict available in Scottish Courts. It means the prosecution have not provided enough proof to convict a Defendant but the jury wasn't prepared to go as far as Not Guilty. In England & Wales, the verdict in those circumstances would be Not Guilty. Anyone given a verdict of Not Proven has nonetheless been acquitted.

Charge 2: Breaches of ANO
(a) Failing to keep proper records: Not Guilty (Unanimous)
(b) Failing to ensure pax were familiar with Safety Procedures, as required by the company Ops Manual: Guilty (Majority)


Well done, Al Gwilt.
Your expert evidence was obviously important - and clearly stood up to cross-examination by the prosecutor.


Tudor Owen
Flying Lawyer is offline