Vol7,
Whether you like it or not chat rooms occasionally end up hosting a spat between two parties with differing views. You disagree with mine, fine; clearly I disagree with yours. I believe I at least have outlined my views but I do not feel that you have sufficiently articulated yours. You appear content to chuck in a nondescript one liner and withdraw. That boy is cowardice.
I would be very happy to hear your views in more detail and if I am mistaken then I will have no hesitation in admitting I was wrong. However I feel your views, as expressed so far, lack weight and authority and seem to be founded on prejudice and maybe a degree of underconfidence. It is pretty obvious to me that you are not or never have been in a management role, so until you have been I would recommend that you keep your mouth shut and your ears well and truly pinned back. You might actually learn something lad.