Jacko
Ah! So in accepting that there was 'no doubt
earned respect', then
's a third of the way there. And if we can presume that
was generally obeyed without question (reluctant obedience does not necessarily follow 'refused advice'), then
's two-thirds the way there. If your analysis that
wasn't generally liked holds water, then so what? It would desirable to be liked, but it's not essential - whereas I suggest your first two criteria probably are.
Did any of your interviewees reveal a different side to the man, or did you not travel that road?
I've no doubt there are those of us that could recall tales of 'revered' peacetime RAF leaders which would similarly and severely dim the odd halo. Most choose not to (in public): it would be pointless, and potentially hurtful to others.
Mod
Why ---?????