I have been following the thread closely, from the outset, and measuring the replies without further comment since my own.
However, I do feel the need to ask readers what they feel about the one insert by WWW - and I add this:
WWW
I don't think the fuel uplift was unreasonable.
You cannot be serious - surely!?
Are you telling readers, that YOU would take only 15 minutes extra fuel had you been the Commander of that flight?
I wonder how many readers with real airline Command experience would support your veiw of that RAMP fuel decision?
The "poor facilities" you mention - are you talking about NAV aids, or those engaged after the sad event.
I'm glad you engaged your imagination on this one; for I hope never to fly with you in the LHS if you opt and contend it reasonable to carry such fuel loads in those conditions.
Seems the lessons about WX and options have been lost on some F/O's.
TG