Nick,
You would make a good politician as you don't answer the question!
I thought we had already agreed that total aircraft protection is an improvement. I thought that we were trying to have a reasoned debate on the question:
"Is a 1 kg bird at Vh/Vne a sufficiently high standard?"
Unfortunately you have become all defensive again! In your own, figures 11% of all strikes on the windscreen (and elsewhere for that matter) exceed 1 kg. Do you agree that this is acceptable or not?
g33