BM
When and Where did I suggest the DZ's be closed? Your words not mine.
At issue is the procedure. The PJE is either separated from IFR traffic or it is not. This other wishy-washy crap is full of holes that a team of lawyers could drive a truck full of money through.
If the ATC service can provide the separation service (use the radar - remember that mantra from RHS?) then let them do it - properly. Hey, there isn't even a charge for the service!
The only problem with commonsense - it not that common
email uncommon sense