PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - Choose Between Windows XP and Windows 2000?
Old 5th July 2004 | 21:12
  #21 (permalink)  
IO540
20 Anniversary
 
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 13,787
Likes: 0
From: EuroGA.org
I think SATA is a waste of time.

They could have made the SATA controller look like an IDE controller, so every O/S would work just fine, out of the box. But NO..... they make it look like a SCSI controller, you you have to press F6 and insert a floppy/CD with the driver.

But SATA doesn't do the drastic CPU load reduction which SCSI gives you; it is just like IDE actually. So you can get a situation where you have a 3GHz CPU, a SATA HD, and be writing a CD on a CD writer, and when somebody on the LAN prints to an inkjet attached to your PC, the CD writing fails spectacularly. OTOH, you could have a 200MHz CPU, a SCSI HD, a SCSI CD writer, and no matter how you load it up, it won't fall over.

SATA just looks better on paper but for single user situations there isn't any point because the HD can't deliver the data fast enough, and the SATA controller doesn't do the queue reordering, posted writes, etc.
IO540 is offline