ST
Tried that once for a mate with no success
Seems you have to have
Same make (obvious)
Same size
Same Version (that was the hard bit)
and a small Torx driver (also good for pulling mobile phones apart after inadvertant dunking
)
Got to the stage where HD was recognised and platters spun up but no go.
Next stage was to physically transfer the platters but I chickened out about then
It is always worth a try if you need the data
If you REALLY need the data there are commercial companies that do recover data but it aint cheap !
Max