PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - The NAS Debate: Other Opinions
View Single Post
Old 12th Jun 2004, 15:11
  #8 (permalink)  
WALLEY2
 
Join Date: Aug 2003
Location: Australia
Posts: 156
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Questions re VoR and Dick

Q1. The only DAS on a characteristic of NAS is the BME DAS. Are the persons who wrote the report appropriately qualified- are the conclusions, based on the data available, valid?

Q2 The preliminary report was audited by Dr Fulton and Dr Westcott. Do you think it is appropriate that Dick Smith writes to the chairman of the CSIRO seeking action against these CSIRO scientist for their work on this report. Would you consider this as undue influence and very poor behavoir of a person who then claims he has no authority?



DICK: I JUST FOUND OUT ABOUT THIS AND AM BLOODY ANNOYED AT THIS MOST UNAUSTRALIAN AND OFFENSIVE ACTION. ARE YOU BEREFT OF ANY ACCADEMIC DECENCY ON THIS SUBJECT?

YOU HAVE GOT TO LEARN NOT PLAY THE MAN.

WE ARE DEALING WITH SCIENTIFIC EVALUATION OF AIRSPACE. BULLY TACTICS AND SPITEFUL BEHAVIOUR ARE NOT PART OF THE ANALYTICAL PROCESS.

IN YOUR POSTS ON PPRUNE YOU OFTEN STATE 'WHY DON'T YOU RING ME? WHY REMAIN ANONYMOUS?"

NO F@@@@@@ WONDER PEOPLE WILL NOT RING YOU OR WANT TO REMAIN ANONYMOUS.

IT WAS ME WHO ASKED FOR AN AUDIT OF THE PRELIMINARY REPORT, AFTER I WAS ADVISED THERE WAS NO NASIG STUDY THE STUDY TEAM COULD REFER AND COMPARE THE PRELIMIARY RESULTS WITH.

I WAS DELIGHTED WHEN ADVISED THE CSIRO SCIENTISTS WERE GOING TO DO THE AUDIT, NOW I AM ASHAMED I GOT THEM INVOLVED WITH THE LIKES OF YOU AND YOUR DR SEPTIC FELLOWS.

DON'T RING ME FOR 48 HOURS, SO I CAN CALM DOWN AND DONT BERATE MY STAFF FOR NOT GIVING YOU MY MOBILE NUMBER, IT IS RESTRICTED TO FRIENDS AND VIPs. AT THE MOMENT YOU ARE NEITHER

Mike Caplehorn
Chairman BIA Group

Last edited by WALLEY2; 12th Jun 2004 at 16:07.
WALLEY2 is offline