Baldricks Mum:
Whilst I don't get the gist of most of your posts in this place, when you ask what went wrong, perhaps you should ask Dick Smith himself - he is the one who is saying the controller didn't do their job. The way I see it Dick's airspace master plan left the controller with no job to do apart from pass traffic. There is no separation service - that is what we were all screaming about remember (or am I confusing that with an industrial campaign?).
Good to see that AirServices Australia have issued a media release to refute this nonsense.
It must be approaching the point where medical assistance is sought to work this guy out.