I think it's better the was it is at present.
As a low hour PPL, I'm very grateful for the replies from those more experienced than I, to my queries. I have learned a lot from their replies, to my questions, and others.
If I was in a forum for Low hour PPL's then I probably wouldn't be able to benefit from their replies, and they wouldn't venture in. Likewise if I posted a question on the IFR ga forum, it would be moved.
Also I probably wouldn't venture into the student forum, so they wouldn't be able to learn anything from me.
Also many of the questions here are about geography, rather than skills. eg. can someone recommond an airport in Paris, or Dublin....the greater the readership of the forumn, the better chance of receiving a good reply.
There's my thoughts.
dp