PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - Ukraine War Thread Part 2
View Single Post
Old 26th April 2024 | 18:24
  #10317 (permalink)  
Lonewolf_50
Community Builder
Community Influencer
 
Joined: Aug 2009
: Military
Posts: 9,346
Likes: 2,187
From: Texas
An article in Newsweek today.

America's Abrams Tanks Are Failing the Ukraine Test


Story by David Brennan

The tanks provided to Ukraine have reportedly struggled to deal with Russian drones.© Ian Hitchcock/Getty Images

The U.S. is withdrawing its Abrams main tanks from Ukrainian battlefields after the platforms proved unable to deal with the threat of Russian drones, according to two unnamed U.S. military officials who spoke with the Associated Press.

Five of the 31 American Abrams sent to Ukraine since January 2023 have already been lost to Russian action, the AP said. Their delivery came after months of intense lobbying on Kyiv's part, but the armored platforms—along with others supplied by NATO allies—failed to make the decisive battlefield impact that Ukraine had hoped for.

The Abrams—the unit cost of which is around $10 million each—have fallen victim to the mass use of drones over Ukrainian battlefields, with both sides employing surveillance and strike platforms in the attritional fighting that has come to characterize Russia's invasion.

Their constant presence in the air has made it difficult to amass and move high-value weapons systems like the Abrams close to the front.

"There isn't open ground that you can just drive across without fear of detection," a senior defense official told reporters Thursday, as quoted by the AP.

Joint Chiefs of Staff Vice Chairman Admiral Christopher Grady and a third, unnamed source confirmed to the AP that the surviving tanks had been withdrawn from the front, with the Americans and Ukrainians now planning to review tactics for their use.

"When you think about the way the fight has evolved, massed armor in an environment where unmanned aerial systems are ubiquitous can be at risk," Grady said.

"Now, there is a way to do it," he added. "We'll work with our Ukrainian partners, and other partners on the ground, to help them think through how they might use that, in that kind of changed environment now, where everything is seen immediately."

Newsweek reached out to the Pentagon and the Ukrainian Defense Ministry by email to request comment.

Russian propaganda has been giving prominence to videos and images of defeated Western tanks.

"There is nothing unusual in this tank in the way it is praised by the West and Ukraine," one soldier with the callsign Izai told the state-run Tass news agency. "It left a poor impression and I expected something more."

Moscow has repeatedly vowed to destroy the advanced Western weapons systems sent to Ukraine, claiming that aid from the U.S. and its allies will only prolong—not help win—Kyiv's existential defense war.

Last September, for example, Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov told reporters at a press briefing, "There is no panacea, no single weapon that can change the balance of power on the battlefield."

As to Western weapons, he said: "They too will burn."
A few points.
1. No weapons system is magic.
2. Ukraine does not have air superiority, and neither do the Russians.
3. Abrams was built under the air land battle assumptions of the 1980's and upgraded based on Force XXI concepts a couple of decades later.
4. If you can't fight a combined arms battle, you will often come up short.
5. Seems smart to come up with some new TTPs, as is mentioned in the article, rather than simply providing Russian drone pilots with some target practice.

But I want to ask this, from the opening line of the article; wait, the US is withdrawing the tanks? I thought they had been given to Ukraine? What is going on here? More Strings Attached? Or has Ukraine chosen to pull them back unitl better tactics/schemes are developed?
Lonewolf_50 is offline