The rate my xyz sites are moderated to avoid abuse and it’s not anonymous so there are barriers to avoid victimisation and harassment. There are bad apples in training and in regular line pilots and anyone is capable of attempting to tarnish reputations.
On the other hand; the point would be that the really toxic folk do get poor ratings and something can be done about it. The advice to junior crew to write reports is to be frank; idealistic and a bit naive. Junior crew prioritise protecting their own career and just deal with it. That’s a less than optimum outcome for everyone.
Also I too have experienced QRHs being “annotated” by characters who thought they knew better than the manufacturer. The contrast between their own self image and what other crew members actually thought of them could not have been more extreme. Sad to see.
Last edited by Boeingdriver999; 3rd June 2023 at 07:24.