Originally Posted by
John Nichol
Hmmm. I really don't think these 2 tragic incidents can be described as 'similar' other than an element of human failing being involved. Which is true for many, many incidents.
I fully describe Budgie's in TORNADO - his Hawk out of control because of a servicing error involving aircraft controls. And a subsequent ejection out of parameters.
I also cover Sean's incident in EJECT - a sequence of largely unlinked occurrences, including the ejection seat servicing error, which resulted in a truly awful accident witnessed by one of my friends.
With access to both Boards of Inquiry, I am WELL aware of the vagaries of both incidents, and especially the controversy surrounding Sean's accident (I had met him with my family a few months earlier during a visit to the Reds. We also met Jon Egging that day - another sad loss for the RAF and especially of course, his loved ones).
I know this is an ongoing discussion on other forums, but other than the human failing aspect, would suggest there is no common theme other than the tragic death of 2 fine pilots.
Indeed, Budgies death was nothing to do with the seat, but everything to do with norms in the unit riggers involved of not following a maintenance proceedure to the letter and independent inspections not being raised for such. The Sergeant rigger on that shift I had the misfortune to work for later. It was not hard to see why things went wrong. He should have been asking, where is the independent inspection for this task? Of course duty of care didn't exist.