“… make sure in the SIM you did what the checker expected/would accept simply to get the tick in the box and …”
I cringe at such statements, but this and the supporting views are realistic.
galdian
(BraceBrace similar)
Most situations in aviation - in life, depend on context; on how we interpret the immediate situation, and that this will not be the same as in the simulator (its only a simulation - not real), and its unlikely that the required action will be as in the book.
I do not know why Airbus differs from Boeing, possibly differences in philosophy.
Airbus considers design and technology to protect pilots from themselves, with margin to think. Boeing allows pilots to choose to do (to think) as they wish, then controls with procedures and rules.
The important issue is to think about the situation before it arrises - consider the context, safety priorities, required outcome. At least you will have a basis for defence, but don't expect anything better than a draw from discussions with the Chief Pilot, Training Capt, or anything which is written, which is never as in real situations.
Re the opening question, don't expect an answer, only opinion; think for yourself beforehand because its your opinion which is important, on that day, in a real situation.