Personally I think Qantas requirement is fantastic. I now get to sit back and watch the bottom 10% of the pilot gene pool throw a tantrum and have to weigh up whether they really believe that Facebook page that forms the basis of their 'research', run by a fully qualified garbage collector is worth their job.
Might even free up a few commands.
Most entertaining. I can't think of a quicker and more effective way to collectively improve the mean IQ of the Qantas pilot group.