Totally agree with everything previously written, unless the instructor briefed something different, it is a Severe Damage situation.
In the company I work at, a few years ago they introduced a "feedback" channel where these incidences could be anonymously reported to the training department. they are also available to be read un edited by the pilot group. There is also the opportunity to comment on the feedback, so if it has happened to more than one crew, the others can add their weigh to it.
This has had a very positive effect in curbing the Rouge Instructor/Check captain behaviour.