I have just registered to this forum after reading M.85's post, I have these comments.
God forbid that any of us ever have to cope with the circumstances that caused this accident. I don't think anyone on this forum is trying to hang this crew out to dry.
What we are hoping to do as pilots is to try and learn something out of this tragedy and it is entirely correct IMHO that professionals should be able to dabate this accident.
We all want to fly more safely and we all hope to learn by studing the circumstances surrounding any accident. I am sure that there are professionals that contribute to this forum that are involved in Crew Licencing and SOP reviews. If this kind of debate ultimately leads to safer flying, then we should embrace it.