I have one of those Awards I am thinking.....as I seem to recall standing around one day with not much to do and wound up being pulled into a line up and provided a Participation Trophy.
With some effort I might be able to dig it up out of the cardboard boxes of clutter down in the cellar.
That Year we were proved adept at notching an "X" in the appropriate places on the Retired USAF General's Metrics he had set forth as the Judging Standard and offset by who had won the previous Year's Award as I recall. The Competition is amongst the US Department of Energy Aviation Units and who knows what the judging criteria is today.
Hopefully under new and different management it has improved over those many years ago.