PS: Lookleft, please let us know what experience/knowledge. you have on relevant aircraft.
Yes, I'm wondering the same thing after this line:
I have flown a 737 in full manual reversion and it was a non-even
Anyone with any time on the B737 will know that the expression "full manual reversion" refers to flying the thing without any hydraulics to the flight controls, which has NOTHING to do with the pitch trim. Having instructed on this sequence both in the sim and the aeroplane, and had it actually happen to me requiring a lurching return, I can assure you that it's not a mere "non event", as he claims. But maybe he's an ace - I'm certainly not.