PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - MAX’s Return Delayed by FAA Reevaluation of 737 Safety Procedures
Old 5th Oct 2019, 22:22
  #2906 (permalink)  
yanrair
 
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: dublin
Posts: 2
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Originally Posted by Byros
Every week that passes we learn more information about the flawed & corrupt certification process for the 737-MAX, a plane that burns less fuel at the expense of safety.

Boeing prioritizes profits above safety, the FAA is infiltrated by Boeing, and the eventual loss of life has been deemed acceptable.

Boeing's PR machine still tries to disseminate the "just fly the aircraft" mantra in many ways to try and divert attention from a flawed 737-MAX design, while trying to imbue pilots with some sort of blame.

Good evening Byros.
I don't think you have been paying attention to the thousands of postings on this forum. They fall into three main groups and none have a right to claim the moral high ground yet since we don't really know, do we? So you asserting that 'Boeing prioritizes profits above safety, the FAA is infiltrated by Boeing, " is a touch in dodgy territory I would suspect.
CAMPS
1 Boeing is the devil and deliberately created a flawed machine and are wholly culpable for everything that happened. Boeing should hang its head in shame. FAA too.
2 Boeing created a very good plane with a bad fault which went to to contribute to two crashes, which however were avoidable if the pilots had acted correctly. Remember that the first Lionair did land safely. So fix the Max AND train the rest of the world's pilots to a higher standard.
3 As per 2/ above but that it was not recoverable or avoidable by an "average pilot". So if we fix the MCAS on the Max, problem solved. No need for further training except of course to do a course on how MCAS works in its new incarnation.,
You seem to be in camp 1 with a dash of Camp 3 thrown in.
I really wish you were correct because in two months or so, in your view, it will all be over and the fix will be in place and nothing like this will happen again.
Unless and until we get another multiple failure like AF 447, or ET or Turkish 738 at AMS, (and many others) where the pilots are "overwhelmed". QF 32 was a situation which could have overwhelmed the crew were it not for their training and airmanship.
And note that AF and QF were not Boeings.
Cheers
Yan


yanrair is offline