As SLF, I have to say that I have mixed opinions about this thread along with others. It's good to see the exchange of technical information and detail. There is evidently an enormous amount of expertise on display. This is reassuring.
Less so are the disagreements. I've once been in the unfortunate position of overhearing two medical consultants argue over a course of action the outcome of which held some relevance to my continued existence.
Yet. The board is for debate. There may come a time in your careers when you need to consider how you would react in situation X. If it isn't covered by documented procedures, I guess that some degree of highly informed guesswork must creep in.
So carry on. These moments at altitude are when you earn the sort of money you should be earning.