Originally Posted by
Ian W
It doesn't seem a particularly difficult task although the avionics architecture separation may make it less simple.
- The ADIRUs receive mismatching AoA, instead of reporting 'Unreliable Airspeed' they should just disregard AoA inputs and report 'AoA Mismatch'.
- Then as AoA is mismatched it has to be assumed that MCAS is receiving the incorrect AoA, so
- Disable MCAS,
- Steps 1 - 3 can only be reset by maintenance with weight on wheels
- If MCAS is essential then AOG until AoA reporting is matched and test flown.
I also think using the input from two AoA sensors would allow an almost foolproof foundation. With any understanding of data science, voting out the faulty should not be hard - and if not possible, due to both providing sane enough data, that could lead to a different outcome.
But we need to allow killing MCAS without killing the electrical trims.