Flying for Fun
Regarding your first sentence in your last post.
Does it mean to sound so arrogant? Are you qualified to pick holes in his instructors views?
Perhaps you are an instructor yourself. If that's the case how would you feel having your views discussed openly on this forum?
Sounds to me like Airdog had a bad experience and the instructor agreed that a g/a was not an option so as not to shred the confidence out of him.
If you really would like to make a formal enquiry why not do it by Private Message.