1. Umbrella emasculates our union for the foreseeable future leaving us completely open to any new attack on T&Cs
2. Defined as a “turd with sprinkles” even by it’s main NC supporter
3. Doesn’t come close to what was polled as minimum for HKPA
4. Is a reduction in terms of ARAPA
5. Contains an offensive 1% “payrise” when everyone else just got 3%. Forget about keeping up with inflation if we accept this. In fact, forget about ever getting another payrise once POS18 get trained up
6. Gives the company everything they want in exchange for all the above