Sometimes you need to know the subject matter in order to evaluate the official response. Much like a newspaper report the next day, of an incident that one has witnessed, can read like a different event, the AAIB reports seem fine unless you know the truth. Then the small cracks appear, and you have to wonder what else they got wrong.
I agree, and that is why there needs to be an open and independent inquiry into the Clutha accident AND the Moray Firth accident. The point that I tried to make is that you have to apply the same criteria to both cases.
DV