PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - HKG MD-11 Crash Video Released
View Single Post
Old 9th October 2003 | 03:13
  #16 (permalink)  
Bokomoko
 
Joined: Nov 2000
Posts: 101
Likes: 0
From: sunny country
From the evidence contained within the video (and only from that) I can draw no conclusion other than it is a horrendous design fault with the aircraft - IMHO there is no evidence of pilot error at all here. (please feel free to disagree!)

Sorry DtA, but I have to disagree. With throttles reduction to idle at 50ft and airspeed decreasing almost 20kt prior to flare a very hard landing was definitely unavoidable. Night landing, poor visibility, MLW, low speed, high sink rate and attitude, crosswind and crab angle are a sequence that can lead to unforeseen results for any heavy jet airplane... Therefore, it's not an 'exclusive' MD11 design fault.
Bokomoko is offline