PPRuNe Forums - View Single Post - AF 447 Thread No. 12
View Single Post
Old 24th Mar 2018, 12:57
  #1613 (permalink)  
KayPam
 
Join Date: Dec 2015
Location: France
Posts: 507
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
This post was a real grammar exercise for me because everything is written in the conditional tense !

He points out very troubling things regarding the Habsheim accident.
He shows pictures and newspaper articles for both of the following :
- The pilot (Asseline) would have received not one but two fake licenses, after his license was confiscated (by the same authority)
- The black boxes would have been tampered with by the BEA, and they would even have given the judiciary investigators fake blackboxes (he shows pictures with different marking patterns on the black boxes)

He also says things very troubling about France :
- He would have been declared mentally ill by state doctors, whereas private doctors signed several certificates saying he was not crazy*
- He would have been followed and threatened by state agents**
- He would have been forcefully sent to mental asylums even though he was not crazy*
All that because he said things that were obviously causing a trouble.

*Of course, staying focused on the same topic for 30 years despite all the problems it caused him is the sign of a slight deviation from the norm. But not the kind of deviation that would justify denying him his medical, or sending him to an institution.


Like you said, today, it certain that FBW is not outright dangerous in itself.

So I think we can conclude that one of several hypotheses is true :
1 - The Habsheim crash revealed a small defect with the 320 (either the normal law, or the fadec, or the engine itself..). Jacquet was too much of a pain in the ass, so the state decided to shut him up. Then even though the 320 problem was solved (with a simple software update), the man never changed his mind. At this stage, his mind and jugement could also have been polluted by several years of fighting against something he cannot beat (the state and airbus), and it's plausible he won't support any airbus system for the rest of his life.

2 - Or, there was never a problem with the 320 to begin with, and the state just destroyed this man for no reason.

3 - Or, everything could be made up bull****, but that seems improbable since there are many articles proving at least 2.

**You can google things like "rainbow warrior" to find that the French state was not always "white as snow" as the French saying goes.
KayPam is offline