PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   USA (https://www.pprune.org/usa-43/)
-   -   Delta Flight lands at wrong airport on 7/7 (https://www.pprune.org/usa/581343-delta-flight-lands-wrong-airport-7-7-a.html)

Lonewolf_50 11th July 2016 21:02


Originally Posted by Hotel Tango (Post 9436381)
If you look at the photograph above you may note the close proximity of the airbase and the airport. Therefore, the airbase tower must be quite used to seeing inbound traffic to the civil airport. If, as in this case, an aircraft makes a sudden approach to their own runway I would imagine there's not much one can do in the very short time involved. Don't forget that the aircraft will not be on the airbase frequency. Best they MIGHT be able to do is ensure their runway is clear and then just watch the aircraft land.

They could transmit on Guard telling the aircraft approaching RWY XX to wave off/go around. The USAF is not known to be shy about transmitting on guard. :E

Hotel Tango 11th July 2016 22:03


They could transmit on Guard telling the aircraft approaching RWY XX to wave off/go around. The USAF is not known to be shy about transmitting on guard.
Sure they could, and for all we know maybe they did. We don't know the facts yet. Equally there may have been no traffic activity at the base and therefore no reason for the controller to be looking out of his tower cab just in case an airliner, piloted by a qualified crew and equipped with multiple navigational aids might be erroneously making an approach to the base!

vector4fun 12th July 2016 01:26

I used to work at the airport at the bottom of the photo. You'll notice there's a nice, long, parallel runway not far away at the top of the photo:

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikiped...ld_-_Texas.jpg

Desert air, visual approaches from 20 or 30 miles out common, lots of smart pilots lined up on the wrong airport/runway. A few even landed on the wrong one. But we did catch most errors before they became news fodder or reportable incidents.

Thing is though, I still recall my first flight into ELP, and briefing my commercial student that there were two airports in close proximity, and we'd make darn sure we saw both, and were looking at the correct one before we did something dumb.

neville_nobody 12th July 2016 12:20

Excuse my ignorance but what is the norm for arrival brief and setup in the US?

How hard is it to tune up the ILS or program a runway extension? Surely that would resolve any ambiguity that would arise. And yes I get it that there are runways everywhere in the US but in this day and age to line up on the wrong runway is almost inexcusable given what is available in RNP capability.

Sailvi767 12th July 2016 14:30

Pilots at Delta are required to back up any visual approach with all resources available. If a IFR approach is available it should be set up in the box and tuned. If not a extension should be built off the runway.
One thing to be aware of is that operations into smaller US airports is quite different then anything you might find in Europe. You are often cleared for a visual and released to the common freq or tower 30 miles out. How you get to the airport is up to you. Not that many years ago you could get a cruise clearance and it might still be in use. We would be cleared to cruise Bozeman airport from 100 miles out in a 727. Everything after that was up to the pilot.

er340790 12th July 2016 14:41

Ryanair have been mistaking Charleroi for Brussels for years... :oh:

Hotel Tango 12th July 2016 15:04

:) but that's only by 26nm. Frankfurt Hahn is 50nm from the city!

sitigeltfel 12th July 2016 16:17

How can you lay that at the door of RYR when the airport describes itself as Brussels South ?

Brussels South Charleroi Airport

Hotel Tango 12th July 2016 18:01

Because Ryanair "encouraged" them to do so when they started flying there? Same thing for Hahn and a host of other RYR airports.

Biggles78 14th July 2016 12:57

How long had they been flying that day (sectors) and what was their roster like for the previous month? Could fatigue have played a part here?

aer lingus 16th July 2016 09:35

ww.irishtimes.com/news/ryanair-flight-to-derry-lands-at-military-airfield-1.1289817
Eirjet flying on behalf of Ryanair lands at Ballykelly military base instead of City of Derry. 2006.

bloom 16th July 2016 10:03

"How long had they been flying that day (sectors) and what was their roster like for the previous month? Could fatigue have played a part here?"

Hah! This happened in the US ! The NTSB here in the states is only concerned about the previous 72 hours and nothing more!

slast 17th July 2016 10:14

Londonderry event actual report can be found at
http://picma.org.uk/sites/default/fi...ondonderry.pdf

captjns 20th July 2016 21:17


Originally Posted by er340790 (Post 9437710)
Ryanair have been mistaking Charleroi for Brussels for years... :oh:

I'll throw out the BS card on this one being a large distance between the two airports and 4 letter identifiers in FMC for EBCI versus EBBR.

pattern_is_full 20th July 2016 22:27

captjns - it's a sarcastic joke, as in airlines mistaking Crawley (Gatwick) for "London," or Grapevine (DFW) for "Dallas," or Ontario/Burbank/Orange County for "Los Angeles."

At least here in Denver, when we built an airport 30 miles out in the suburbs, we annexed the land, so the runways really are in "Denver." ;) Sort of.

Airbubba 20th July 2016 23:35


Originally Posted by pattern_is_full (Post 9446525)
captjns - it's a sarcastic joke, as in airlines mistaking Crawley (Gatwick) for "London," or Grapevine (DFW) for "Dallas," or Ontario/Burbank/Orange County for "Los Angeles."

There is a famous story, perhaps apocryphal, of Fiorello LaGuardia and his ticket to New York:


At one point, Fiorello refused to get off a "Washington-New York" flight that landed at Newark Airport in New Jersey. He was finally flown to Bennett Naval Airfield in Brooklyn when he declared "I bought a ticket to a New York airport." This was a publicity gimmick that resulted in the city acquiring North Beach in which an airport was built. It was renamed in his honor as LaGuardia Airport. There is a wonderful bust of him inside the Marine Air Terminal of LaGuardia Airport.
Fiorello LaGuardia -- America's Mayor --

West Coast 20th July 2016 23:51


At least here in Denver, when we built an airport 30 miles out in the suburbs, we annexed the land, so the runways really are in "Denver." Sort of.
Have you gone down Tower road of late? The city is quickly moving to close the gap. Pena is gonna have to buy and sell some more land pretty soon further out.

Or maybe they could build another E-W runway and actually use the two they have.

pattern_is_full 21st July 2016 03:09

Well, Peņa has been out of the equation for over 20 years. He left 3 years before the airport opened.

But you're right, we're filling in the 1-mile-wide-by-15-miles-long "gerrymander corridor" of former wheat fields we "negotiated" away from Adams County. And other cities (Commerce City, Aurora) are also growing out to meet the airport's borders.

West Coast 21st July 2016 05:36

That's because he made his money off the airport deal and moved away.

tdracer 21st July 2016 22:49


Have you gone down Tower road of late? The city is quickly moving to close the gap.
And how long before those new residents start complaining about the noise :ugh:


All times are GMT. The time now is 20:30.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.