PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Tech Log (https://www.pprune.org/tech-log-15/)
-   -   Determining reliable altitude (https://www.pprune.org/tech-log/665424-determining-reliable-altitude.html)

extricate 9th April 2025 07:55

Determining reliable altitude
 
Hi,

What is the best way to determine a reliable altitude given altimeters including standby altimeters are inop after takeoff? Also taking into consideration that radar altitude is inaccurate too. Will 1-in-60 rule be helpful in this case?

Thanks for the knowledge.

Regards

Gargleblaster 9th April 2025 08:00

Your GPS may be indicating your height ? Your transponder might also still be sensing and emitting altitude, so ask ATC what they're seeing ?

Tu.114 9th April 2025 08:08

In such a situation, also be sure to check the other air data instruments for validity. With a failure in the static pressure system, the air speed indicators are gone as well, so a good start would be the Unreliable Airspeed Indication checklist applicable to Your type.

Depending on the FMS installation and the nature of the failure, You might find air data readouts and/or GPS altitudes on some pages.

lurkio 9th April 2025 13:49

Surely if the altimeters are unreliable due to a feed problem the data going to the transponder will also be unreliable. GPS (if installed) is the way to go. And it will be altitude not height.

extricate 11th April 2025 11:03

I’m not sure on the major jetliners, GPS altitude will be available?

Amadis of Gaul 11th April 2025 13:26


Originally Posted by extricate (Post 11864668)
I’m not sure on the major jetliners, GPS altitude will be available?

What about on minor ones?

Capn Bloggs 11th April 2025 14:48

Use the weather radar ground return tilt angle until you get on the ILS glideslope at 6000ft/20nm.

EXDAC 11th April 2025 15:22


Originally Posted by extricate (Post 11863179)
Hi,

What is the best way to determine a reliable altitude given altimeters including standby altimeters are inop after takeoff? Also taking into consideration that radar altitude is inaccurate too.

What failure will cause loss of all barometric altimeters and also cause radio altitude to be inaccurate? Did the person who taped all the static ports also put high speed tape on the radio altimeter antennas?



tdracer 11th April 2025 16:51


Originally Posted by Gargleblaster (Post 11863187)
Your GPS may be indicating your height ? Your transponder might also still be sensing and emitting altitude, so ask ATC what they're seeing ?

This would probably be one of the worst things you can do. Your transponder does not have an independent altitude sensor and will be using the same suspect numbers as the rest of the aircraft.
This is what doomed the Aeroperu 757 - they were trying to fly using the transponder altitude (as relayed by ATC) and hit the ocean when they thought they were (IIRC) 6,000ft.
Radio altitude would be your best bet unless GPS altitude is available.

applecrumble 11th April 2025 20:42


Originally Posted by Capn Bloggs (Post 11864782)
Use the weather radar ground return tilt angle until you get on the ILS glideslope at 6000ft/20nm.

Are you able to elaborate please Capn Bloggs

rudestuff 12th April 2025 08:23

The GPS will probably know it's height, but will have no way of displaying this to the crew as we don't use GPS heights. If you have no altimeter info then you've also got much bigger problems. You'll also likely have unreliable airspeed as well.

Brian Pern 12th April 2025 09:08

I assume its a pressurised aircraft, if so depressurise and see what the Cabin Altitude indicator says. Failing that has your phone/ipad got GPS?

pilot-737 13th April 2025 18:06


Originally Posted by applecrumble (Post 11864972)
Are you able to elaborate please Capn Bloggs

Terrain function -> calibrated gain -> tilt-8.25 degrees(for a 3.5 beam like A320 WX radar antenna). The distance at which you notice the first returns, is your height above the ground in 1000 ft.

If WX radar inop, you can depressurize your cabin (provided you stay below 10000ft) and read the cabin altitude(adjust the value for non standard QNH).

Speed_Trim_Fail 13th April 2025 20:38


Originally Posted by extricate (Post 11864668)
I’m not sure on the major jetliners, GPS altitude will be available?

It is available, and on the airbus I fly it can be seen both on the FMGC MCDU but also via the backup speed scale if equipped.

CVividasku 14th April 2025 19:20

I would use delta P and a barometer that I have on me.
I have two barometers with me at all times, my watch, my phone, I'm pretty sure my ipad has a pressure sensor too.

This requires a bit of knowledge about standard atmosphere, but hey we're professionals.
FL30, 60, 100, 140, 180, 240, 300, 390 (Easy to memorize, +3, +3 then +4 +4 +4, +6 +6 and +9)

moosepileit 22nd April 2025 20:05


Originally Posted by applecrumble (Post 11864972)
Are you able to elaborate please Capn Bloggs

PMJI...
3 degree pencil beam weather radar, tilt down -8.5 degrees. Ground return distance is your absolute height. 10,000' paints ground at 10NM. 5000' paints ground at 5NM', enough to find an ILS GP.

Or, find the landing area radar reflectors and cook up your own final like back in the day.

Rule of 60, 1000'/NM is a 10 degree angle. Assumes an IRU stabilized radar airliner/big biz jet platform, otherwise compensate for deck angle.

It's just a radar tilt confidence check, in reverse. Mind the goats climbing hills and obstacles.

moosepileit 22nd April 2025 20:05


Originally Posted by applecrumble (Post 11864972)
Are you able to elaborate please Capn Bloggs

PMJI...
3 degree pencil beam weather radar, tilt down -8.5 degrees. Ground return distance is your absolute height. 10,000' paints ground at 10NM. 5000' paints ground at 5NM', enough to find an ILS GP.

Or, find the landing area radar reflectors and cook up your own final like back in the day.

Rule of 60, 1000'/NM is a 10 degree angle. Assumes an IRU stabilized radar airliner/big biz jet platform, otherwise compensate for deck angle.

It's just a radar tilt confidence check, in reverse. Mind the goats climbing hills and obstacles.

moosepileit 22nd April 2025 20:05


Originally Posted by applecrumble (Post 11864972)
Are you able to elaborate please Capn Bloggs

PMJI...
3 degree pencil beam weather radar, tilt down -8.5 degrees. Ground return distance is your absolute height. 10,000' paints ground at 10NM. 5000' paints ground at 5NM', enough to find an ILS GP.

Or, find the landing area radar reflectors and cook up your own final like back in the day.

Rule of 60, 1000'/NM is a 10 degree angle. Assumes an IRU stabilized radar airliner/big biz jet platform, otherwise compensate for deck angle.

It's just a radar tilt confidence check, in reverse. Mind the goats climbing hills and obstacles.


All times are GMT. The time now is 03:04.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.