PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Tech Log (https://www.pprune.org/tech-log-15/)
-   -   Coffin Corner (https://www.pprune.org/tech-log/332202-coffin-corner.html)

redout 22nd June 2008 16:09

Coffin Corner
 
How is the correct way to escape from Coffin corner. Is it by Descending to a "safer" altitude while carefully controlling airspeed ?

BOAC 22nd June 2008 16:11

Well, we don't recommend climbing.

Ayla 22nd June 2008 16:36

Just don't go there in the first place. Know your buffet margins. If you are foolish enough to end up in that predicament your solution would work.

BOAC 22nd June 2008 16:47

No it won't! The definition of CC is that ANY increase or decrease in speed will result in loss of control, so basically you are Gordon Ramsey'd as we say on UK TV.

Sentence 1 rules.

rubik101 22nd June 2008 16:51

Surely you mean Gordon Ramsey'd. Jamie is just a cockney lad who uses slang, but he doesn't swear on TV!

Lots more power might help.

BOAC 22nd June 2008 17:04

Whoops! Yes I do.:O Thanks. Edited. I actually watch neither, so please may I be excused?

redout 22nd June 2008 17:26

BOAC what is the ans ? How does one escape without killing themselves.

gr8shandini 22nd June 2008 18:56

Actually, the term "coffin corner" refers to a very small window between mach buffet and stall, not loss of control. And it is possible to maintain a given airspeed while descending, is it not? This is a very high altitude phenomenon, so you'd likely be at a pretty high power setting and all you have to do is reduce throttle. In fact not many aircraft have enough motor to get themselves into this situation to begin with.

airfoilmod 22nd June 2008 19:06

Well
 
Reduce power and.... Stall. No increase left, at max altitude, can't climb, At Vne can't descend, you going to do uh What?? Including the word Coffin is not a mistake.
rubik: more power than wing has killed many an inattentive pilot.

Airfoil

fireflybob 22nd June 2008 19:06

BOAC is, as ever, correct!

Why would you want to go there? You don't save fuel by climbing early above optimum.

BOAC 22nd June 2008 19:08

I believe the actual 'coffin corner' was a one-way street, that real control loss was supposed to happen there with ANY change in Mach or IAS. It would require consumate skill to 'lower the nose' and fly out of it without increasing Mach no or reducing IAS. I suspect it was more a notional 'media' thing rather than a real one, but I'm sure someone will know better.

Ironically, for 'rubik', "Lots more power might help." - it was the converse. Too little power stopped people from getting up there as Lear pilots have discovered the hard way.

rcl7700 22nd June 2008 19:28

Sounds hard to reach such a critical Coffin Corner situation where ANY changes involve a Stall or Overspeed? Seems very hard to even approach this situation without stalling or overspeeding beforehand. You will always have some margin which is the way you would get out.

If you somehow get to such a critical situation I think anybody would rather have an overspeed in the recovery process than a shaker.


rcl

airfoilmod 22nd June 2008 19:32

Coffin Corner "sounds hard to reach". Only if you can't imagine flying well past it. It isn't a destination, it's no man's land. It's real, have faith and believe.

Airfoil

FE Hoppy 22nd June 2008 20:09

In a modern Airliner you can't get near "coffin corner" without busting MMO so we should coin a new term for the limiting alt where MMO and AoA stall coincide.

Any suggestions?

How about Certifications Wall?

airfoilmod 22nd June 2008 20:36

What about
 
Hard "Hat"

BOAC 22nd June 2008 21:04

redout - if you look at the bottom of the page you will see several threads about CC. Our friend John Farley posts (at #14) in one of them a good description of the situation.

Looks like your original question is best asked of a U2 pilot.

Kiwiguy 23rd June 2008 07:00


Reduce power and.... Stall. No increase left, at max altitude, can't climb, At Vne can't descend, you going to do uh What?? Including the word Coffin is not a mistake. rubik: more power than wing has killed many an inattentive pilot.
Airfoil you can reduce power and use attitude to maintain airspeed. Airspeed is the critical factor.

Just don't apply for a job as a carrier pilot if you don't understand that sink can be controlled EITHER by attitude or power. You add new lustre to the term plain driver ... sorry I meant plane driver. :8

Brian Abraham 23rd June 2008 08:22

Believe the U2 had a spread of about 10 knots.

BOAC 23rd June 2008 08:53

That's a big chunk of Mach, Brian - you sure? I assume that was at 'normal' operating altitude rather than any 'higher'?

Dont Hang Up 23rd June 2008 09:06

The Chuck Yeager Approach
 
To recover from CC.Tumble in an uncontrolled manner out of the sky until you hit thicker air. Ultimately you will recognise the uncontrolled state has now entered a recognisable aerobatic state (spin or inverted spin). Apply standard recovey technique. Simple.


All times are GMT. The time now is 02:34.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.