PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Tech Log (https://www.pprune.org/tech-log-15/)
-   -   737 Control Wheel Grip (https://www.pprune.org/tech-log/656514-737-control-wheel-grip.html)

flypaddy 23rd Dec 2023 09:29

737 Control Wheel Grip
 
I’ve just started converting to the 737 and find the control wheel an awkward shape. If I put my thumb in reach of the trim switches I find my index finger resting on the PTT and my middle finger resting on the intercom rocker. It feels like a firm grip during a gusty approach would have me accidentally transmitting. I don’t recall this being a problem on the 757, 767 or 787. My hands are neither unusually large or small!

Perhaps I’ll get used to it but I’d be interested to hear how others recommend the control wheel is gripped.

Capt Fathom 23rd Dec 2023 10:01

I’m sure Boeing have put some work into this. You’ll get used to it. Or you can give up flying! :E

oceancrosser 23rd Dec 2023 10:25

Ancient 1950’s control wheel. Never liked it. Luckily I got off the 737 fairly quickly.

Chesty Morgan 23rd Dec 2023 10:27

Is this serious?!

- Don't grip so firmly.
- Stick your fingers out a bit and grip with the other two.
- Don't be PF.

Flying Wild 23rd Dec 2023 15:53

I've never found myself needing to trim on a gusty approach? What's the problem?

RetiredBA/BY 23rd Dec 2023 16:15


Originally Posted by flypaddy (Post 11561284)
I’ve just started converting to the 737 and find the control wheel an awkward shape. If I put my thumb in reach of the trim switches I find my index finger resting on the PTT and my middle finger resting on the intercom rocker. It feels like a firm grip during a gusty approach would have me accidentally transmitting. I don’t recall this being a problem on the 757, 767 or 787. My hands are neither unusually large or small!

Perhaps I’ll get used to it but I’d be interested to hear how others recommend the control wheel is gripped.

Get a grip old boy !

stilton 25th Dec 2023 07:15


Originally Posted by flypaddy (Post 11561284)
I’ve just started converting to the 737 and find the control wheel an awkward shape. If I put my thumb in reach of the trim switches I find my index finger resting on the PTT and my middle finger resting on the intercom rocker. It feels like a firm grip during a gusty approach would have me accidentally transmitting. I don’t recall this being a problem on the 757, 767 or 787. My hands are neither unusually large or small!

Perhaps I’ll get used to it but I’d be interested to hear how others recommend the control wheel is gripped.


I flew the 727 which has the same yoke, I found it very comfortable but everyone’s different, it takes a deliberate input to press the PTT switch so don’t worry about that, it’s highly unlikely you will and if you do you’ll know anyway


Enjoy your flying and don’t be concerned about something that’s unlikely to happen

Uplinker 26th Dec 2023 11:24

Oh dear.......a few replies no doubt meant in jest, or fuelled by Christmas port, but like the old crusty types who could not actually teach but just gruffly snapped if we were doing something wrong. Come on guys, you're better than that !

I only flew the '73 (Classic), for one season, it is a very poorly designed aircraft from the pilot interface point of view. I had no trouble but cannot remember much about it to help the OP.

Possibly, you are being too tense, so just try to relax. Think of the aircraft in gusty conditions more like a boat that you are guiding on a heavy rolling sea - don't try to prevent it moving, but try to anticipate and gently counter any movement away from your desired attitude and flightpath, and just keep bringing it back to where you want it. Smoothness !

olster 26th Dec 2023 11:52

Actually uplinker that is good advice. One of the keys to accurate flying is to relax and not grip the control wheel too tightly.

B2N2 26th Dec 2023 13:48

The 73 has the control wheel of a WWII submarine and a trimwheel no doubt invented during the Spanish Inquisition.
Just manhandle that sunnofabeach.

ZeBedie 26th Dec 2023 17:45

Does the 737 still have noisy microswitches which click every time you move the yolk from its neutral position?

Fursty Ferret 28th Dec 2023 02:40

Relax your grip on the wheel.

Go on YouTube, watch a few videos of people flying in gusty conditions in the 737, and endeavour to do the opposite. While frantically thrashing the controls around does little more than look good on TV, it makes passengers feel sick, puts you at risk of PIO, and makes it difficult for PM to assess your inputs. It also translates very badly to any other type, particularly a heavy FBW aircraft.

flypaddy 28th Dec 2023 20:40

Thanks for (some of!) the replies. I’ve found the root cause of the issue. The simulator has a rocker for PTT and intercom which is spring loaded in both directions; hence the concern about either intermittently transmitting or hitting intercom.

It transpires that this is not representative of the real aircraft and the intercom side of the rocker is not sprung, so I can grip the switch as I have on all my previous Boeings without subjecting the FO to incessant clicking.

framer 29th Dec 2023 08:04

That’s good to hear Paddy, it sounds to me like the sim needs to be updated.

ImbracableCrunk 29th Dec 2023 16:35


Originally Posted by ZeBedie (Post 11562554)
Does the 737 still have noisy microswitches which click every time you move the yolk from its neutral position?

Maybe, but you can't hear it over the other noises. Ops Check OK.

Rt Hon Jim Hacker MP 29th Dec 2023 17:04

The trim wheel is also a thing of beauty. Had a jump seat ride on one a few years back when I joined a new employer. Lucky for me, I was employed to fly the A320 series with 8 years on type.

ACMS 30th Dec 2023 07:12

It’s a real Aircraft, all the Airbus Boeing haters can go take a long walk off a short pier……I’ve got a lot of hours in both and I know which one I prefer.

Uplinker 30th Dec 2023 09:47

Yawn.........

ACMS 30th Dec 2023 10:20

Exactly, the whole topic is a yawn…….

stilton 1st Jan 2024 04:59


Originally Posted by ACMS (Post 11564374)
Exactly, the whole topic is a yawn…….


Not too tiring to read though


All times are GMT. The time now is 00:04.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.