PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Tech Log (https://www.pprune.org/tech-log-15/)
-   -   Airspeed indicators in EAS (https://www.pprune.org/tech-log/646214-airspeed-indicators-eas.html)

RBF 15th Apr 2022 12:48

Airspeed indicators in EAS
 
Quick question that just popped into my mind.

Is there any reason for not having modern airspeed indicators showing EAS instead of IAS?

I mean, after all, dont airplanes really "fly" according to EAS?

Vessbot 15th Apr 2022 13:51

Pure speculation, but I think there's a good chance that the position, installation, and compressibility error corrections are applied by the computer to the speed before we see it, thus making it actually EAS; but they don't label it that because IAS is the entrenched common term, and you don't want to confuse pilots.

Goldenrivett 15th Apr 2022 14:21


Originally Posted by Vessbot (Post 11215849)
Pure speculation, but I think there's a good chance that the position, installation, and compressibility error corrections are applied by the computer to the speed before we see it, thus making it actually EAS; but they don't label it that because IAS is the entrenched common term, and you don't want to confuse pilots.

I don’t think there is any compressibility correction.
Please see Old Smokey thoughts from 15 years ago.

EXDAC 15th Apr 2022 19:36


Originally Posted by RBF (Post 11215809)
Is there any reason for not having modern airspeed indicators showing EAS instead of IAS?

How can the airspeed Indicated on an Air Speed Indicator be anything but Indicated Air Speed? Indicated means exactly that - the speed that is indicated by the indicator. No matter what compensation, calibration, or correction is applied it is still Indicated Air Speed.

Shouldn't the question be - why can't IAS be equal to EAS?

Vessbot 15th Apr 2022 22:38


Originally Posted by EXDAC (Post 11215974)
How can the airspeed Indicated on an Air Speed Indicator be anything but Indicated Air Speed? Indicated means exactly that - the speed that is indicated by the indicator. No matter what compensation, calibration, or correction is applied it is still Indicated Air Speed.

Shouldn't the question be - why can't IAS be equal to EAS?

Sometimes etymological origin doesn’t map nicely onto technical usage. In this case, after about a hundred years when indicators have become capable of indicating things unthinkable originally - but the need to keep track of some of the speeds before correction has been applied, has remained, leading to some ambiguity.

If you automatically say that whatever is shown is IAS, then you lose the ability to talk about pre-correction speeds. Like most modern jets that indicate TAS as well as IAS - do we get confused and say oh my God, there’s one IAS and another IAS that differs by 50%? Of course not. We know that of the two speeds that are literally indicated, only the one labelled IAS is the aeronautical definition of IAS.

Back to the original question about EAS, now I’m more siding with Goldenrivett and don’t think that they’re showing us EAS without telling us (like I was suggesting before) as it can be a 20-25 knot difference in cruise, and I think it’s a significant enough difference (hopefully, at least) they wouldn’t sneak it by us.

But I did look at what my manual says, and (not explicitly, but suggestive language) that what is displayed on the PFD is CAS.


Vessbot 15th Apr 2022 22:44

A neat aside, on the SR-71…

https://cimg2.ibsrv.net/gimg/pprune....5a1dc2634.jpeg

EXDAC 15th Apr 2022 23:21


Originally Posted by Vessbot (Post 11216034)
But I did look at what my manual says, and (not explicitly, but suggestive language) that what is displayed on the PFD is CAS.

I don't know that all aircraft use the same terminology but what Honeywell and Douglas displayed on the MD-11, MD-90, and 717 PFD was Computed airspeed. I could provide a bit more detail on the derivation if needed. I would argue that the indicated airspeed was CAS (Computed Air Speed not Calibrated Air Speed). TAS is a separate numeric readout that is clearly identified as TAS on the flight decks I worked on.

Alex Whittingham 16th Apr 2022 08:42

It's a CS.25 requirement I think, CAS. I vaguely recall one type (Embraer?) showing EAS.


All times are GMT. The time now is 07:36.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.