PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Tech Log (https://www.pprune.org/tech-log-15/)
-   -   APU Master ON before takeoff (https://www.pprune.org/tech-log/626326-apu-master-before-takeoff.html)

MD83FO 14th Oct 2019 00:18

APU Master ON before takeoff
 
What are the consequences of having the APU master ON before takeoff, and back OFF sometime after?

Roj approved 14th Oct 2019 02:50


Originally Posted by MD83FO (Post 10593725)
What are the consequences of having the APU master ON before takeoff, and back OFF sometime after?

The flap will be open

Tomaski 14th Oct 2019 12:04


Originally Posted by Roj approved (Post 10593758)
The flap will be open

Unless the APU is still running from the before taxi/engine start phase. In that case, the ram air door will have cycled closed. Having the master switch on without the APU running will cause the ram air door to open which will add somewhat to the drag profile and increase chance of FOD ingestion without any real benefit.

vilas 14th Oct 2019 12:52


Originally Posted by MD83FO (Post 10593725)
What are the consequences of having the APU master ON before takeoff, and back OFF sometime after?

And why would you do that?

Tomaski 14th Oct 2019 13:39


Originally Posted by vilas (Post 10594097)
And why would you do that?

If someone is actually putting the master switch on without the APU running, then I'm guessing they want to get a leg up on a possible APU start after takeoff (engine failure, generator drops off line, etc) since they won't have to wait for the ram air door to cycle open. My thought would be if they are really that concerned, then just start the APU. That said, I understand some airlines track APU usage by flight crews and discourage unnecessary use. This may be one person's technique of threading the needle between having the APU readily available during takeoff and not getting a call from their Flight Department about excessive APU use.

vilas 14th Oct 2019 16:47


If someone is actually putting the master switch on without the APU running, then I'm guessing they want to get a leg up on a possible APU start after takeoff (engine failure, generator drops off line, etc) since they won't have to wait for the ram air door to cycle open
I doubt if this could be the reason. EFATO is not such a deadly emergency that you require APU in a split second. ECAM or STATUS don't even mention APU start. Starting of APU is only mentioned in FCOM Abnormal procedure There cannot be procedures for phobias.

Uplinker 14th Oct 2019 17:15

Maybe the OP pressed the APU master switch by mistake before T/O and wonders if there are any consequences?

Many moons ago, at TOD inbound to Heathrow in our BAe146, I noticed the APU was still running. Ooops ! :)

Tomaski 14th Oct 2019 17:15


Originally Posted by vilas (Post 10594234)
I doubt if this could be the reason. EFATO is not such a deadly emergency that you require APU in a split second. ECAM or STATUS don't even mention APU start. Starting of APU is only mentioned in FCOM Abnormal procedure There cannot be procedures for phobias.

I never said it was a good reason, but I can see the thought process that gets you there.

matsemann 14th Oct 2019 19:18


Originally Posted by Uplinker (Post 10594258)
Many moons ago, at TOD inbound to Heathrow in our BAe146, I noticed the APU was still running. Ooops ! :)

All 5 of them?

IAEdude 14th Oct 2019 19:22


Originally Posted by matsemann (Post 10594325)
All 5 of them?

Brilliant :D

FlightDetent 15th Oct 2019 03:40


Originally Posted by MD83FO (Post 10593725)
What are the consequences of having the APU master ON before takeoff, and back OFF sometime after?

Perplexing idea, but I flown under rules that mandated APU on for LVP and similar. 🤷🏼 (now imagine if such idea came from the NAA perhaps you'd be pressed to reinvent the wheel a little).

1) The flap will be open. Looking at the MEL items where the APU is left running, there may be no performance penalty. Hm, actually it would not be thrusting nor sucking even a little, with the open inlet in this scenario causing net parasitic drag - so perhaps check with CDL and the OEM is needed to formally tick all the boxes.

2) Some less insightful people might think it is actually a good idea. 🤔

3) Something happens in the electric system with Master SW on (cue emerg elec proc), so worthwhile researching if that is relevant and with consequences or not.

4) the wear of the switch push-button and system contractors is increased.

(recorded in order of appearance).

Uplinker 15th Oct 2019 09:52


Originally Posted by matsemann (Post 10594325)
All 5 of them?

Ha ha !

Remind me how many successful civil jet airliners Norway has designed and built ?

:)

matsemann 16th Oct 2019 20:28


Originally Posted by Uplinker (Post 10594766)
Ha ha !

Remind me how many successful civil jet airliners Norway has designed and built ?

:)

None, we are just too busy drilling for oil ;)

FlyingStone 16th Oct 2019 23:28


Originally Posted by Tomaski (Post 10594127)
If someone is actually putting the master switch on without the APU running, then I'm guessing they want to get a leg up on a possible APU start after takeoff (engine failure, generator drops off line, etc) since they won't have to wait for the ram air door to cycle open..

Most modern-ish aircraft work perfectly fine on single generator, bar the ovens and IFE - which isn’t a concern unless you are a certain European airline that likes to fly across Europe on a single engine.

FlightDetent 17th Oct 2019 16:08

On a late 80's designed jet, dropping 1 ENG GEN cuts the IFE, aft galley and half of the fwd galley. There one oven and one coffee-maker remain operative - guessing that without them it would be a real emergency.

Tomaski 17th Oct 2019 18:52

Been away from the MD-80 for awhile, but what I recall from this situation is the concern over something happening to that single engine-driven generator until the APU started. With one generator, the APU had an electric starter assist. Without, you were down to a windmilling start (to preserve the battery) which could take a while if you were not well inside the starting envelope. Not a huge problem in VMC conditions, but IMC was a different story.

MD83FO 18th Oct 2019 01:47

thanks for the injunctions, my train of thought is, ok, mitigation of bird damage on initial climb when warranted, accelerate above 3000' where most bird impacts occur, secondly be ready for a dual engine failure and emergency electrical config by having the APU ready to start, it doesn't seem to affect in any way normal operation.
the A350 starts the APU automatically when needed.

vilas 18th Oct 2019 02:21


Originally Posted by MD83FO (Post 10597174)
thanks for the injunctions, my train of thought is, ok, mitigation of bird damage on initial climb when warranted, accelerate above 3000' where most bird impacts occur, secondly be ready for a dual engine failure and emergency electrical config by having the APU ready to start, it doesn't seem to affect in any way normal operation.
the A350 starts the APU automatically when needed.

In dual engine flame out all you have to do is press three buttons the MASTER, ON and BLEED and in 40 seconds you will have it. APU bleed is pressure sensitive switch only opens at correct pressure.


All times are GMT. The time now is 07:18.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.