E170/190 Angle of Attack
Hi all,
The E170/E190 series doesn't have angle of attack vanes. How does it sense AoA? |
Smart probes.
http://utcaerospacesystems.com/cap/s...%20Systems.pdf |
PFM principle.
|
And now for the real killer. These aircraft use the "Smart" data to drive the flight path vector. The flight path vector cannot be removed from the PFD. After a few hundred hours you forget the actual pitch associated with any aspect of your flight. You and the autopilot merely drive the FPV onto the flight path target. What could possibly go wrong? Erm... birdstrike (bee strike), pitot heat, writing, leak, system failure etc. followed by one EICAS message and a double ding you now are flying with invalid FPV data. You have three systems and one or two of them are telling lies. You can't get rid of the FPV and possibly both sides have different FPV values (or both are wrong, both are right or No. 3 is invalid, but it's not displayed) and the pitch you need is... Oh, and you need to kill the auto throttle before it kills you as a well.
I notice they don't crow about how simple it is to deal with system failures. |
I had a look on smart probes website, but it still puzzles me how they derive AOA from a probe what looks like a pitot probe.
|
Originally Posted by Chesty Morgan
(Post 9809179)
Smart probes.
http://utcaerospacesystems.com/cap/s...%20Systems.pdf |
Originally Posted by gearlever
(Post 9810267)
I had a look on smart probes website, but it still puzzles me how they derive AOA from a probe what looks like a pitot probe.
|
Originally Posted by Piltdown Man
(Post 9810206)
And now for the real killer. These aircraft use the "Smart" data to drive the flight path vector. The flight path vector cannot be removed from the PFD. After a few hundred hours you forget the actual pitch associated with any aspect of your flight. You and the autopilot merely drive the FPV onto the flight path target. What could possibly go wrong? Erm... birdstrike (bee strike), pitot heat, writing, leak, system failure etc. followed by one EICAS message and a double ding you now are flying with invalid FPV data. You have three systems and one or two of them are telling lies. You can't get rid of the FPV and possibly both sides have different FPV values (or both are wrong, both are right or No. 3 is invalid, but it's not displayed) and the pitch you need is... Oh, and you need to kill the auto throttle before it kills you as a well.
I notice they don't crow about how simple it is to deal with system failures. |
It's a flight path angle on the EJet PFD. Not a Vector.
And the pitch attitudes are in the QRH |
Those who need the QRH to know their pitch attitudes have bigger problems than an FPA indication.
|
On the 190, the design philosophy seems to have been that attitude is a secondary parameter, as the FD only shows the flight path you need, and not the pitch. It's a most asinine system.
|
On the 190, the design philosophy seems to have been that attitude is a secondary parameter
Have things changed in the magenta following world that pilots or should they now be called aircraft operators no longer fly pitch and power= performance, they just blindly follow a vector! |
Perhaps at the Embraer factory. Thankfully Boeing and Airbus still know what they're doing.
|
Originally Posted by Amadis of Gaul
(Post 9811580)
Those who need the QRH to know their pitch attitudes have bigger problems than an FPA indication.
|
Experience, my brother, experience.
|
Originally Posted by simmple
(Post 9811758)
Have things changed in the magenta following world that or should they now be called operators no longer fly pitch and power= performance, they just blindly follow a vector!
|
So you can remember ALL combinations of pitch and power for every airspeed, weight, altitude, aircraft configuration, climb, cruise, descent and holding?
Because at the last count there are 115 different combinations in my QRH with plenty of interpolation available. |
And for those banging on, the CSeries has FPV as primary too.
Like the Ejet, the pitch indication is always in view and the same style pitch tables are available in the QRH. Welcome to the 21st century ;-) no bits of string tied to the windscreen required. |
Originally Posted by Chesty Morgan
(Post 9812127)
So you can remember ALL combinations of pitch and power for every airspeed, weight, altitude, aircraft configuration, climb, cruise, descent and holding?
Because at the last count there are 115 different combinations in my QRH with plenty of interpolation available. |
No you don't because some clever chap has published then for you.
The correct use of airmanship is an amazing thing. The incorrect use of ego isn't. |
All times are GMT. The time now is 02:31. |
Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.