PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Tech Log (https://www.pprune.org/tech-log-15/)
-   -   A320 family. There are two approach techniques (https://www.pprune.org/tech-log/582880-a320-family-there-two-approach-techniques.html)

StrIA 12th Aug 2016 07:43

A320 family. There are two approach techniques
 
‐ The decelerated approach
‐ The early stabilized approach.
http://savepic.net/8377726.jpg

- How will be named approach technique, when a/c passes the FAF in CONF 2 or 3? - How will be named approach technique if approach performs via CDFA (Continuous Descent Final Approach)?

Cough 12th Aug 2016 08:02

If you are not stabilised at VAPP at the FAF, then the approach is decelerated.

IMHO, as long as you are at an appropriate speed at the FAF (with F1 selected minimum - F2/F3 may be needed for steeper/tailwind approaches) there isn't an issue.

If the CDFA approach is flown in Final APP, then decelerated approach is fine. If the CDFA is flown using V/S or FPA for the vertical mode, then I would opt for early stabilisation.

StrIA 12th Aug 2016 12:34

If terminal chart doesn't contain FAF, it will be decelerated or early stabilized approach?
http://savepic.net/8350859.jpg

*Lancer* 14th Aug 2016 00:26

There is always a FAF. If it's not indicated, it is the Final Descent Point (GS intercept).

sonicbum 14th Aug 2016 09:25


There is always a FAF. If it's not indicated, it is the Final Descent Point (GS intercept).
Hi Lancer,

if it's not indicated, there is no FAF, there are several procedures built that way. You can check the DOC8168 - ARRIVAL AND APPROACH PROCEDURES - NPA WITHOUT FAF.
Now if we are talking about FAP it's a different story and yes it is the GS intercept.


If terminal chart doesn't contain FAF, it will be decelerated or early stabilized approach?
It will be an early stabilized approach but you have to ensure that your operator allows you to fly non-CDFA approaches like in the case of a NPA without FAF. Your picture though represent an ILS.

m-dot 14th Aug 2016 09:47

Frenglish in FCOM. The FAF in effect refers to the final descent point.
1. Early stabilised = LDG CFIG @ VAPP at final descent point.
2. Decelerated = not Early Stablilised.

vilas 14th Aug 2016 10:08

StrIA
The particular approach you have depicted which I take it as an ILS can you do a decelerated approach? You have 1313 feet to land from FAP or GS interception. You have to be stabilised by 1000ft. or 3 nm before threshold. That leaves you only 313 ft. or 1.2 nm to configure to Vapp on the GS which is impossible. You have no option but to arrive at GS interception point with Vapp.

vilas 14th Aug 2016 15:24

*Lancer*
ILS approaches do not show FAF. The Maltese cross if it is there is the FAF of the localiser approach. For the ILS approach GS interception point is named Final Approach point. Basically it was named so as to identify the beginning of the ILS approach so you can legally continue to minima even if weather goes below minima.

sonicbum 14th Aug 2016 19:36

Hi vilas,


Basically it was named so as to identify the beginning of the ILS approach so you can legally continue to minima even if weather goes below minima.
I do not see the correlation between the FAP and the wx deterioration below minima. You can start and continue any kind of approach until the OM/equivalent point/1000 ft AAL regardless of the weather conditions. You need to have the minima by the above mentioned point at the latest to continue down to your minima.

vilas 15th Aug 2016 06:37

sonicbum
Quoted below from Jeppesen The Chart Clinic 21st in a Series:


A number of years ago, the FAA created a definition for the final approach fix on precision approaches. Because FAR Part 121 and 135 operators can continue the approach if the weather goes below minimums and the airplane has passed the final approach fix, it was necessary to define a precision FAF when using the glide slope.



Gryphon 15th Aug 2016 07:18

Approach ban
 

Originally Posted by vilas (Post 9474027)
sonicbum
Quoted below from Jeppesen The Chart Clinic 21st in a Series:


A number of years ago, the FAA created a definition for the final approach fix on precision approaches. Because FAR Part 121 and 135 operators can continue the approach if the weather goes below minimums and the airplane has passed the final approach fix, it was necessary to define a precision FAF when using the glide slope.



Sonicbun = EASA AirOps (but only 1000ft AAL, not OM or equivalent anymore)
Vilas = FAA

sonicbum 15th Aug 2016 08:39


Sonicbun = EASA AirOps (but only 1000ft AAL, not OM or equivalent anymore)
Vilas = FAA
Hi Gryphon, thanks for the clarification :ok:

StrIA 15th Aug 2016 12:29


Frenglish in FCOM. The FAF in effect refers to the final descent point.
1. Early stabilised = LDG CFIG @ VAPP at final descent point.
2. Decelerated = not Early Stablilised.
Thank's for your response

StrIA 15th Aug 2016 12:31

vilas
Thank's

FlightDetent 15th Aug 2016 13:21

Just a picture ...
https://ctrlv.cz/shots/2016/08/15/HTzs.png

I-WEBA 15th Aug 2016 17:48

What is the difference between point "D" and point "P"?

FlightDetent 15th Aug 2016 21:45

P is the FAP (published glide slope intercept), IF the intermedieate fix. D is calculated by the charting provider as a convenient position to start final descent.

In this case, it actually helps and is relevant to the published Airbus guidance.
Which is (for decelerated approach)
- Intercept G/S at S speed and CONF 1, at 2000' AAL set FLAP 2, then gear down then the rest successively. Stable at 1000.
- If the intermediate altitude is at 2000' AAL or lower[*], set flaps 2 at G/S one dot below, and gear down with G/S intercept.
[* = but not below 1500 ft AAL].

StrIA's picture has one solution: intercept final at 5.1 WGD, be fully stabilized at that point already, it is close and low.

Mine offers a different technique: to keep 600 meters from the IF, flying level with S speed and CONF 1, and use the second / short version of Airbus OEM decelerated approach described above - using the "D" position. Of course, you do not really need a chart to do it this way, but it is more comfortable and reassuring with it to crosscheck and more importantly, plan ahead.


All times are GMT. The time now is 07:34.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.