PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Tech Log (https://www.pprune.org/tech-log-15/)
-   -   what speed when both engines fail (https://www.pprune.org/tech-log/478540-what-speed-when-both-engines-fail.html)

seifly 28th Feb 2012 14:58

what speed when both engines fail
 
What speed to use when both engines fail and you have to drift down in a B737

bubbers44 28th Feb 2012 15:05

It must be cold up there in Minnesota to be pondering that. Maybe any speed above clean min naneuvering clean would work depending on where you decided to land. Ask Sully.

skyhigher 28th Feb 2012 15:11

from the classic QRH from my company;


At or above FL270, set airspeed to 275 knots.
Below FL270, set airspeed to 300 knots.

below fl100 i would start to reduce towards min clean.

hope this helps.

MD80rookie 28th Feb 2012 15:12

V clean above FL200 for stall margin, Vp clean below FL200 is used in my airplane for drift down on one engine. If both went silent, I would use V clean if clean, and Vp for whatever config I have.

/Rookie

twochai 28th Feb 2012 16:13

I have always thought that the best L/D speed is achieved at approximately 1.6Vso, but I'm not sure I can document the reasoning.

MD80rookie 28th Feb 2012 16:28


I have always thought that the best L/D speed is achieved at approximately 1.6Vso, but I'm not sure I can document the reasoning.
That is equal to Vclean, which is 1.5 Vso!

Love the restart idea though... :O

B737-800W 28th Feb 2012 16:38

To make numbers simple:

Above FL100 = 280kts
Below FL100 = Fup speed

Dont forget to be configured!!!

Regards

B737-800W

FE Hoppy 28th Feb 2012 16:44

OK465, I'm with you. Windmill relight until I've got some air then assist after that.

Denti 28th Feb 2012 16:52

Why not just follow the loss of thrust on both engines checklist? Says in step 5 in mine for the 737NG:

At or above FL270 set airspeed 275knots. Below FL270, set airspeed to 300knots.

However, below FL100 i would start looking where to set it down and slow down to up speed.

HPbleed 28th Feb 2012 16:58

Depends what you want to achieve. Don't you have a QRH?

B737-800W 28th Feb 2012 17:06

Denti,

i agree 1000000%, follow the QRH.:ok:

The numbers that i said before are just some figures to have at the back of your mind.

The question by our friend was not, what is the best speed for a windmill start.
The question was about Gliding Speed!!!

Regards

Denti 28th Feb 2012 17:14

Ah, righto. Best glide should be right at up speed from what i remember, well, probably slightly above.

Johnny Tightlips 28th Feb 2012 17:36


At or above FL270 set airspeed 275knots. Below FL270, set airspeed to 300knots.
I think those speeds are to help with engine restart and not to do with the best glide speed. At that stage of the checklist it is assumed that at least one engine will restart. Funny enough the last two options on the loss of thrust on both engines are either one or both engines restart. It mentions nothing about both engines failing to restart:D

Basil 28th Feb 2012 17:43

I'm retired and haven't flown a big jet for some years but 250kn and sort it out from there flashed up in my head:ok:

Breakthesilence 28th Feb 2012 18:13

Well, if run out of fuel or any abnormal/emergency situation that led to a double engine out without chances to restart, I'd set the Vclean and hope to have a strip within my gliding range (for the B737 Classic, a good rule of thumb is 2.5 x Height)

Check this out, really interesting:

Loss of Thrust on Both Engines

Ciao

Capn Bloggs 28th Feb 2012 21:55

RTFQ.

Cost index 0. Best range speed. :ok:

FE Hoppy 28th Feb 2012 23:54

RTFQ?

He says you have to drift down. Why is that a range question? It could just as easily be a terrain question or a don't kill the pax with hypoxia question or many others.

bubbers44 29th Feb 2012 00:00

FE, I agree, if your airport is near where you lost both engines get down first then at low altitude use min clean speed until you need to configure for landing. Dead sticking an airliner isn't hard, you just can't get low.

hawker750 29th Feb 2012 09:28

what speed when both engines fail

seifly, are you a permanent pessimist; surely If both engines fail is more appropriate?

RAT 5 29th Feb 2012 12:34

And 275kts at FL370 would be interesting.


All times are GMT. The time now is 03:58.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.