PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Tech Log (https://www.pprune.org/tech-log-15/)
-   -   ICAO vs State R/T Differences (https://www.pprune.org/tech-log/324098-icao-vs-state-r-t-differences.html)

Mister Geezer 24th Apr 2008 00:15

ICAO vs State R/T Differences
 
Just wondering where each state will publish any different R/T phraseology from ICAO standard that they wish to use?

I know we have CAP413 in the UK but I am lost as to what other states will use.

BusBoy 24th Apr 2008 02:36

local languages!!
Often in France have no idea as to what is going on around you due to clearances in French, same in Spain.
Only a couple of times has it been a real issue for me eg when we have been cleared for take off and only because we have seen an aircraft turning very short final have we queried. :ugh:

Mister Geezer 24th Apr 2008 03:06

I am referring to differences in phraseology rather than language differences.

john_tullamarine 24th Apr 2008 03:53

would expect that to be in the local AIP or equivalent

TCAS FAN 24th Apr 2008 08:18

Let's not start creating differences, it's not "R/T" its "RTF", ICAO specify that as the standard abbreviation. Most Contracting States, including UK have adopted it, although you could be excused for doubting that when many documents originated by the mandarins at CAA still use "R/T".

Mister Geezer 24th Apr 2008 11:41

Actually the CAA have been very public in highlighting the differences that they have adopted in the UK. NATS recently made a DVD for aircrew to hammer home what the UK differences are and why the CAA have decided to use these different items of phraseology!

I have not seen (in the UK at least) any mention in any AIP as to what the differences from ICAO are, so I suspect it is not a requirement for such details to be published in a AIP!

hvogt 24th Apr 2008 11:50

Hello Mister Geezer

according to ICAO Annex 15 Appendix 1 the AIP shall include information on radio communication procedures under section GEN 3.4. This shall include

"a statement concerning the ICAO documents on which the service is based and a reference to the AIP location where differences, if any, are listed [...]"

Mister Geezer 24th Apr 2008 12:22

Lovely... thanks for that!!!


All times are GMT. The time now is 04:42.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.