PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   Spectators Balcony (Spotters Corner) (https://www.pprune.org/spectators-balcony-spotters-corner-52/)
-   -   Unbelievable A380 landing (https://www.pprune.org/spectators-balcony-spotters-corner/600390-unbelievable-a380-landing.html)

ILS27LEFT 5th Oct 2017 20:59

Unbelievable A380 landing
 
Absolutely unbelievable.
https://youtu.be/roS6oFjCDhc

golfyankeesierra 5th Oct 2017 21:21

Guys (or gals) who flap their rudder like that usually just transitioned from helicopters..
Does Emirates have direct entry pilots from heli's?:}

pilotguy1222 5th Oct 2017 22:01

Yeah, they will be in the sim after that trip ends.

+TSRA 5th Oct 2017 22:09

I dare say it was completely believable for the people sitting 230 feet back from the cockpit who were thrown about like rag dolls if that video is at actual speed.


I get that the surface area of an A380 will require additional rudder input that my lowly Q400 does not, but a little care for passenger comfort and attempting to find a better method for dealing with crosswinds and gusts goes a long way. Most passengers don't mind a little more roll than normal, but boy do you hear from them if you give them any sense of feeling in yaw.

Vessbot 5th Oct 2017 22:12

Anyway, we see the effects of late-phase rudder inputs feeding back into the oscillation instead of damping it. Left swerve, corrected by right rudder. But it also self-corrects to the right due to the natural directional stability, and the pilot maintains the right rudder too long. So both those effects combine into a right swerve. So the pilot puts in left rudder but maintains it too long, etc.

RAT 5 5th Oct 2017 22:16

On finals it looks a little like pilot induced dutch roll. The aileron & rudder inputs were not too coordinated. The lack of finesse with rudder was further demo'd during the flair. I've not flown FBW or side-sticks. From those with hands on knowledge is this common or difficult in your early days? Having said that would EK put AB newbies directly onto A380? Surely not. OTOH we all have bad days occasionally.

Musician 5th Oct 2017 22:18

That should be today's EK55 to Düsseldorf, arriving 11:31z on runway 23L, with a variable 20G32kt crosswind.

Metar:
EDDL 051150Z 30020G32KT 270V330 9999 VCSH SCT030TCU SCT270 16/09 Q1009 NOSIG
EDDL 051120Z 29020G33KT 270V330 9999 FEW016 SCT026 BKN260 15/09 Q1009 NOSIG

atakacs 5th Oct 2017 22:31

What is the 380 crosswind limit? 40knt? In any case seemed pretty much on the edge of reasonable flight envelope. I hope cabin crew at the rear did fasten their harness...

IcePack 5th Oct 2017 22:35

One thing to remember on FBW is that the control surfaces are doing their own thing trying to keep the airframe in it's last commanded position. Hence what you see may not be pilot actions. PIO is often the result of over controlling & not letting the gizmos do their job. The human is often correcting just as the gizmo corrects so over control results. Not sure of the logic blend on the 380. But once on the ground things tend to get conventional with some surprises. e.g. A320 halving the aileron deflection on touch down. My experience is A320/1 & A330.

Field In Sight 5th Oct 2017 22:46

Not on the RUDDER Icepack

Looks like PIO to me.

Direct Bondi 5th Oct 2017 22:53

Rudder:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z8iieqAG-_A

RUDDER.

Volume 5th Oct 2017 22:57

Interesting that they allowed another plane to take off from that runway immediately after, I would have inspected the runway for FOD before...
Good job, Messier Dowty and Goodrich :ok:

Probably the FAs had to clean up the rear galleys after that "landing"

IcePack 5th Oct 2017 22:58

Umm rudder has a yaw damper.

EDML 5th Oct 2017 23:26

... which should be off for a X-wind landing.

Concours77 5th Oct 2017 23:45

What? No castering main gear? What a Dino!

ManaAdaSystem 5th Oct 2017 23:46

Really? Is that an A380 procedure? A 737 is a real handful without yaw damper in conditions like those in the video.
I must be a bad pilot. I hardly use any rudder during approach, only just before touchdown. The guys in the video were properly shocked. Spoilers and flaps left extended when leaving the runway.
Probably two seats now available on the A380 in EK.

Flap62 6th Oct 2017 00:00

Lot of people on here know little or nothing about modern FCS and the 380 in particular. The aircraft is very stable and needs no rudder on approach (although the system may put some in but not as radically and rapidly as the video). Turning off yaw dampers? Welcome to the 1970s. Not even possible.

Standard stuff. Get it on the centreline, at the appropriate height select the landing attitude and smoothly kick off the drift. No adverse roll to worry about.

the_stranger 6th Oct 2017 00:18


Originally Posted by EDML (Post 9915927)
... which should be off for a X-wind landing.

Yeah...

no. At least not on a airbus (380), and I assume also not on other (large) jets.

unmanned_droid 6th Oct 2017 00:26

That's an interesting way of doing things. Not sure I remember seeing that load case in the database.

PoppaJo 6th Oct 2017 00:28


Originally Posted by RAT 5 (Post 9915859)
On finals it looks a little like pilot induced dutch roll. The aileron & rudder inputs were not too coordinated. The lack of finesse with rudder was further demo'd during the flair. I've not flown FBW or side-sticks. From those with hands on knowledge is this common or difficult in your early days? Having said that would EK put AB newbies directly onto A380? Surely not. OTOH we all have bad days occasionally.

EK don’t have a smaller Airbus to pickup the skills unless they joined with previous AB experience.

Usually 777 FO to A380.


All times are GMT. The time now is 02:48.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.