PPRuNe Forums

PPRuNe Forums (https://www.pprune.org/)
-   South Asia and the Far East (https://www.pprune.org/south-asia-far-east-45/)
-   -   737 excessive rotation speed - a hard act to follow (https://www.pprune.org/south-asia-far-east/553283-737-excessive-rotation-speed-hard-act-follow.html)

sheppey 21st Dec 2014 07:59

737 excessive rotation speed - a hard act to follow
 
Recently, an incident came to light involving an Indonesian registered Boeing 737 that would astonish Pprune readers used to hairy events common to that part of the aviation world. Edited for brevity. The take off run started on a 10,000 ft length runway.

The crew were apparently unaware of a problem with the captain's ASI until the 80 knot call by the first officer who was PM. The captain elected to keep going. The F/O called V1 and VR from his own ASI which was working normally. The captain continued the take off roll despite his own ASI giving a significant erroneous reading.

Approaching the end of the 10,000 ft runway the captain's ASI read 80 knots and the captain was forced to rotate to avoid an over-run. The aircraft then flew normally. Investigation revealed the actual ground speed at rotation was 298 knots, exceeding the maximum tyre speed limitation by close to 100 knots. A hard act to follow.

Qantas_A380 21st Dec 2014 08:10

Groundspeed
 
298 Knots!!!! Must be a world record for a 737 take off.

I imagine that the aircraft would have required an extensive inspection of both landing gear assemblies (if the incident was indeed reported at the end of the flight!!). Did they return to base or continue on to original destination?

Are there any other dangers associated with exceeding maximum tyre speed other than burst tyres & landing gear issues?

atakacs 21st Dec 2014 08:21

737 excessive rotation speed - a hard act to follow
 
Geez... I'm really surprised that they did not burst all their tyres!

fireflybob 21st Dec 2014 08:42

You can't beat having a few extra knots for the wife and kids....

BOAC 21st Dec 2014 09:37

Why didn't he loop it?

framer 21st Dec 2014 10:14

:p
Thanks BOAC.
Maybe the Captain had been reading up on 'improved climb' ?

Qantas_A380 21st Dec 2014 10:21

At least climb performance with an engine out was going to be adequate!!

Centaurus 21st Dec 2014 10:26


A reflection on CRM in that particular environment that the FO didn't seem to take over and complete the take off themself.
In some Asian cultures - and others - there is no way an F/O would ever take over from the captain who is regarded as a Deity. We have various acronyms to describe flight safety issues. CRM/TEM/CFIT for example. The latest is LOF or Loss of Face:D

Ka8 Flyer 21st Dec 2014 10:30

Flap overspeed by at least 50 knots. Quite impressive safety margins...

Qantas_A380 21st Dec 2014 10:30

No warnings on the 737 for exceeding max tyre speed?

Or disabled because of ASI disagree?

ZFT 21st Dec 2014 10:34

Do you actually believe this?

I would wait until there is at least something more factual to back this up.

framer 21st Dec 2014 10:42

I'd believe anything after some clown in SE Asia tried to get a 737 to land at a ridiculous speed ( may have been 200kts) about half way down the runway a few years back. The f/o was squawking a bit but didn't actually intervene. This seems mild by comparison.

Paracab 21st Dec 2014 10:44

737 excessive rotation speed - a hard act to follow
 
At what speed will the thing finally give in and start flying anyway?!! Short of having the stick pushed forward!

FlyingStone 21st Dec 2014 11:00


Originally Posted by Quantas_A380
No warnings on the 737 for exceeding max tyre speed?

Or disabled because of ASI disagree?

No warning, although it's quite easy to do it during Improved Climb and hot & high operations...

DaveReidUK 21st Dec 2014 11:34


At what speed will the thing finally give in and start flying anyway?!! Short of having the stick pushed forward!
That was my first thought, too.

Frankly, the whole thing sounds apochryphal. But if any can provide a link to the investigation report of what would surely have been classified as a serious incident, I'll stand corrected.

de facto 21st Dec 2014 11:41

See,if it were airbus,the stick would have gone up by itself:p
Case of an incapable pilot(s) or pilot incapacitation?

BOAC 21st Dec 2014 12:03

It is probably the World land speed record for a tricycle............

It certainly breaks Gary and George's record in the T5 Lighting at Coltishall all those years back.:)

Mikehotel152 21st Dec 2014 12:23

737 excessive rotation speed - a hard act to follow
 
298 knots on the runway? I'd have to see the report. Sounds unlikely.

BOAC 21st Dec 2014 12:43

MH - remember this is PPrune.........you get what you pay for here

RetiredF4 21st Dec 2014 14:19

And nobody is suggesting, that the human sensors in the cockpit should have noticed that those big markers on the side of the runway were passing along quite rapidly on this takeoff?


All times are GMT. The time now is 07:56.


Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.