PPRuNe Forums - Search Results
PPRuNe Forums

Go Back  PPRuNe Forums > Search Forums
Reload this Page >

Search Results

Register
FAQ
Calendar
Wikiposts
Today's Posts
Search
Vendor Directory
 
Page 1 of 2
1
2
Search: Posts Made By: Organfreak
Showing results 1 to 35 of 45
Search took 0.00 seconds.
Forum: Tech Log
29th Feb 2012, 21:01
Replies: 1,412
Views: 471,684
Posted By Organfreak

Thanks, PJ2, for an erudite and thorough reply....

Thanks, PJ2, for an erudite and thorough reply. :D

I think I (and likely many others) may have been led astray by the BBC documentary that came out before the recorders were found. In it, a...
Forum: Tech Log
29th Feb 2012, 19:31
Replies: 1,412
Views: 471,684
Posted By Organfreak

Replying to myself:

You are correct! Unless this, on p. 72, means something:



Plz pardon my ignorance.
Forum: Tech Log
29th Feb 2012, 19:11
Replies: 1,412
Views: 471,684
Posted By Organfreak

PJ2: Really? Now re-reading the entire...

PJ2:


Really? Now re-reading the entire Interim Report #3! :ugh:
Forum: Tech Log
29th Feb 2012, 15:10
Replies: 1,412
Views: 471,684
Posted By Organfreak

Talking I keep saying this; don't read

Everybody's got an opinion. I've got a bunch of them!

I hope that they fix every single possible thing that might have
contributed to the confusion and crash, no matter how tentative. Sure, that...
Forum: Tech Log
21st Feb 2012, 19:33
Replies: 1,412
Views: 471,684
Posted By Organfreak

Oh, and....speaking of "gratuitous," I'm...

Oh, and....speaking of "gratuitous," I'm speculating (again) that you are the only one here in the forum who doesn't believe the pitots were fouled by ice.
Wanna know what I think? (Probably not.) ...
Forum: Tech Log
21st Feb 2012, 19:29
Replies: 1,412
Views: 471,684
Posted By Organfreak

Grrr Lyman opined: Excuse me sir, with all due...

Lyman opined:


Excuse me sir, with all due deference, I know exactly what I meant when I said that. It most certainly is speculation. I accuse him of nothing, but I suspect that he didn't know,...
Forum: Tech Log
21st Feb 2012, 19:01
Replies: 1,412
Views: 471,684
Posted By Organfreak

Danger Lonewolf50

Eleven seconds (a very long time!) after PF declared, "I have the controls,"
PNF said, “we’ve lost the speeds then,” then, ”alternate law protections." (From Interim Report No 3, Page 10.)

There...
Forum: Tech Log
19th Feb 2012, 05:55
Replies: 1,412
Views: 471,684
Posted By Organfreak

The Blame Game

@RR_NDB:


Yes, of course, and you're right that I was careless when I assumed that was taken into account in point seven (quoted below), as well as my remarks about poor training. Point seven:
...
Forum: Tech Log
18th Feb 2012, 16:15
Replies: 1,412
Views: 471,684
Posted By Organfreak

Somebody please correct me if I'm wrong, but the...

Somebody please correct me if I'm wrong, but the A/P disconnected because of the bad speed data! This hamster wheel is makin' me dizzy!
:yuk:
Forum: Tech Log
18th Feb 2012, 15:59
Replies: 1,412
Views: 471,684
Posted By Organfreak

Lyman asked: It certainly did in this...

Lyman asked:


It certainly did in this case. Without speed data, there can be no autopilot.
Forum: Tech Log
16th Feb 2012, 16:20
Replies: 1,412
Views: 471,684
Posted By Organfreak

The Blame Game

rgbrock1, I fully realize that you went on to clarify and amend the above comment, but I see a number of "damning conclusions," at least the ones that I myself make, from the comfort of my armchair....
Forum: Tech Log
13th Feb 2012, 22:03
Replies: 1,412
Views: 471,684
Posted By Organfreak

inrequentflyer789: The story of an...

inrequentflyer789:


The story of an previously unknown abnormal state of the rudder actuator under specific temperature conditions? Is this comparable?

-Member of The Gretchenfrage Fan Club
Forum: Tech Log
8th Feb 2012, 17:01
Replies: 1,412
Views: 471,684
Posted By Organfreak

ChristiaanJ typed: Well sir, though I...

ChristiaanJ typed:


Well sir, though I take great pride in being fatuous at times, in fact I am a master at it, I say, "No!" I only mentioned this fact as a point of comparison between the two...
Forum: Tech Log
8th Feb 2012, 16:19
Replies: 1,412
Views: 471,684
Posted By Organfreak

Comparing this to Sully's flight

I think it does no good to compare these two flights, even though Cap't. Sullenburger did display great airmanship in the face of no-time-to-think.

Besides the aforementioned A/P issue, Sully had...
Forum: Tech Log
5th Feb 2012, 16:31
Replies: 1,412
Views: 471,684
Posted By Organfreak

The apps training site linked in the previous...

The apps training site linked in the previous post led me to this fascinating article on the topic of upset training.
AeroSafety World: Guidelines in Upset Recovery Training | APS Emergency...
Forum: Tech Log
27th Jan 2012, 18:16
Replies: 1,412
Views: 471,684
Posted By Organfreak

@mm43 That's the first time I've read...

@mm43


That's the first time I've read that idea here, and it certainly makes a lot of sense. A complete lack of physical feedback on those sticks, artificially generated or not. I remain...
Forum: Tech Log
27th Jan 2012, 15:51
Replies: 1,412
Views: 471,684
Posted By Organfreak

Yes....there was a Very Frequent Poster in these...

Yes....there was a Very Frequent Poster in these threads, I forget who, who kept calling Bonin's SS technique "stirring the mayonnaise." It should be reminded that such a technique is much more...
Forum: Tech Log
26th Jan 2012, 21:41
Replies: 1,412
Views: 471,684
Posted By Organfreak

Well, bubbers, I think that AF447 demonstrates...

Well, bubbers, I think that AF447 demonstrates that there is a problem with how "qualified" is being defined these days, both by some penny-pinching airlines, and even the regulatory authorities as...
Forum: Tech Log
26th Jan 2012, 15:27
Replies: 1,412
Views: 471,684
Posted By Organfreak

chrisN said: Well, let's think this...

chrisN said:


Well, let's think this through:
Who here would elect to do that? Somebody on their own volition, or "by committee"? There is very little consensus here, even after all that's been...
Forum: Tech Log
21st Jan 2012, 01:45
Replies: 1,412
Views: 471,684
Posted By Organfreak

@stepwilk I have, I did. All of them....

@stepwilk


I have, I did. All of them. Thoroughly.
Forum: Tech Log
19th Jan 2012, 19:43
Replies: 1,412
Views: 471,684
Posted By Organfreak

Cool @ A380 Jockey

My post is even better if you click on the link! :}

Much of the article expresses ideas that have been posted in these threads (and argued about endlessly). But it was refreshing to see these...
Forum: Tech Log
18th Jan 2012, 21:54
Replies: 1,412
Views: 471,684
Posted By Organfreak

Have you seen this?

A330 Pilot Speaks Out - AF447 (http://af447.typepad.com/af447/2011/11/a330-pilot-speaks-out.html)
Forum: Tech Log
5th Jan 2012, 17:28
Replies: 1,412
Views: 471,684
Posted By Organfreak

It's somewhat interesting to note that Hüttig...

It's somewhat interesting to note that Hüttig claims that no-one present at this simulation was able to get the nose down, while the data shows Bonin applied nose-up inputs almost throughout the...
Forum: Tech Log
31st Dec 2011, 21:53
Replies: 1,412
Views: 471,684
Posted By Organfreak

I quite agree. It is indeed frustrating; however,...

I quite agree. It is indeed frustrating; however, some of these posters were not here in the beginning of the thread(s). I was.

But...


I have been here from the beginning, read all of the...
Forum: Tech Log
31st Dec 2011, 20:58
Replies: 1,412
Views: 471,684
Posted By Organfreak

Spinkleman again

Gee, thanks so much for your sarcasm. :*

I asked the question because, in thousands of posts, it hadn't been mentioned once, until now.
Forum: Tech Log
31st Dec 2011, 20:00
Replies: 1,412
Views: 471,684
Posted By Organfreak

Reply to Herr Spinkleman

As far as I'm concerned, PF's actions are evidence.



OK, that is convincing, thanks.



Good info, then I can put that doubt to rest!
Forum: Tech Log
31st Dec 2011, 18:46
Replies: 1,412
Views: 471,684
Posted By Organfreak

Clandestino wrote: I read Clandestino's...

Clandestino wrote:


I read Clandestino's comment as sarcastic. (?)
Forum: Tech Log
31st Dec 2011, 18:40
Replies: 1,412
Views: 471,684
Posted By Organfreak

Talking OF makes a general speech or lecture

In response to very little, I am moved to post my overall take on all this. I am continually surprised at the polarization of views about this horrible crash. That is, the tendency by some to be in...
Forum: Tech Log
27th Dec 2011, 02:55
Replies: 1,412
Views: 471,684
Posted By Organfreak

There was nothing "plain and simple" about this...

There was nothing "plain and simple" about this accident. It doesn't require an "emotional investment" to hold that view, either.

:=
Forum: Tech Log
26th Dec 2011, 02:16
Replies: 1,412
Views: 471,684
Posted By Organfreak

maajam wrote: Ummmm............. ...

maajam wrote:


Ummmm.............
Because the airplane was at an assigned FL level that was limited by the air temp, the Captain had every right to expect the plane to stay at that level. And...
Forum: Tech Log
23rd Dec 2011, 17:25
Replies: 1,412
Views: 471,684
Posted By Organfreak

Whatever his licenses say, 228 people think that...

Whatever his licenses say, 228 people think that this pilot was unqualified.

I do strongly believe that the AB interface was a contributory factor, but a pilot well-trained in all phases of...
Forum: Tech Log
18th Dec 2011, 21:26
Replies: 1,412
Views: 471,684
Posted By Organfreak

BEagle said, There sure is, but just to...

BEagle said,


There sure is, but just to keep the record straight, I doubt that any pilot, no matter how competent, could have recovered from the Concorde situation. Right?....

As to...
Forum: Tech Log
16th Dec 2011, 19:55
Replies: 1,412
Views: 471,684
Posted By Organfreak

Cliff said: I agree, but the sims people...

Cliff said:


I agree, but the sims people have told us here in the thread that it's not possible due to a lack of real-world test data, IOW, no-one is willing to actually fly that.
Forum: Tech Log
14th Dec 2011, 15:49
Replies: 1,412
Views: 471,684
Posted By Organfreak

Frankie_B wrote: This whole discussion...

Frankie_B wrote:


This whole discussion has already occurred, many pages ago, although I guess it is valuable to have new comments on it. (Something about a hamster wheel?)
The above fact...
Forum: Tech Log
9th Dec 2011, 18:56
Replies: 1,412
Views: 471,684
Posted By Organfreak

Good reply-- AND...there were many facts left...

Good reply-- AND...there were many facts left out, too numerous to mention.

The situation was far too complex to be fairly summed-up in one short article.
Quite a few factors that might have been...
Showing results 1 to 35 of 45
 
Page 1 of 2
1
2


 
Forum Jump

Contact Us - Archive - Advertising - Cookie Policy - Privacy Statement - Terms of Service

Copyright © 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.